Top 10 Episodes Per IMDB


1) Game On, Charles
2) Welcome to the Dollhouse
3) The Lady Killer
4) This Is A Dark Ride
5) Now You See Me, Now You Don't
6) UnmAsked
7) Over My Dead Body
8) The Darkest Knight
9) Taking This One To The Grave
10) A Is For Answers

Are you surprised? Not surprised? What would you change?

I feel like a few of these episodes are up here simply because they had twists or shocking moments (aka both the Ezra and Toby reveals). The dollhouse is considered 'good' because it was something different and shocking. I thought A is for Answers SUCKED. I am surprised about The Darkest Knight being ranked this high as I feel its nothing special and didn't stand out against anything else from seasons 6-7.

The only episodes I feel really deserve top 10 on this list are Over My Dead Body, UnmAsked, and This Is A Dark Ride (which is classic PLL). There are some really good episodes that go under the radar (Please Do Talk About Me When I'm Gone, Love Shack Baby, The Perfect Storm, THE PILOT?!, If These Dolls Could Talk, Through Many Dangers, Toils, and Snares, A Person of Interest).

reply

Taking tbis One to The Grave, Game on Charles, and The DArkest Knight are overrated. A is for Answers is my second fave episode so I can understand and I feel it's UNDERRATED. And yeah, 7x10 should not be there, it was mainly at ships for 30 minutes and the climax was not executed at well at all.

reply

A is for Answers has no place on this list. Snooooooooooooooze. Now You See Me was good for like maybe 3 minutes so nope, shouldn't be here. I really liked Taking This One To the Grave, but since it later became pointless, it doesn't either. IMO Dollhouse and Game On are the only episodes from seasons 4-7 that should be on a top ten list.

But yeah, where in the HECK is "If These Dolls Could Talk"?

The world isn't split into good people and Death Eaters.

reply

I agree with you guys. If These Dolls Could Talk is one of my favorite PLL episodes ever. Also I believe Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Inferno and Will this Circle Be Unbroken deserves to be on the list. And if any episode from Season 7 should be on the list, it should be Hit and Run, Run, Run. Bite Your Tongue, A Kiss Before Lying, Love ShAck Baby(my favorite filler ever) should be here instead of A is for Answers and some other episodes. Now You See Me, Now You Don't is actually my favorite summer finale ever, it was one of the best directed episodes PLL has ever put fourth. Shadow Play, I believe, is highly underappreciated. Joseph Dougherty's direction and Troian Bellisario's performance was flawless.

reply

Hit and Run, Run, Run and Bite Your Tongue are very good.

reply

Funnily enough Shadow Play is the second to last (I believe) episode on the ranking lol

reply

unmAsked is still far and away the best episode of the series so far.

reply

"Welcome to the Dollhouse" and "The Darkest Knight" are overrated. "The Darkest Knight" is my third least favorite mid-season finale. That episodes was boring with ships, Hanna & Emily being dumb dumbs and Nicole being alive (nobody wanted that to happen) "Taking This One To The Grave" was pointless since Mona didn't die and the liars believed Ali was A. I would remove s5ep12 and s7ep10 and replaced them with s2ep24 and s6ep09. "Last Dance" was the last great PLL episode until "Hit and Run, Run, Run". That episode had the wine Moms, Ali confronting Charles, Toby's "I'm a Officer", and the Prom itself was great to look at.

reply

Last Dance was pretty good. As well as Hit and Run, Run, Run. Glad we share the same tastes.

reply

I hated Last Dance! I felt like nothing happened in it.

reply