MovieChat Forums > Pretty Little Liars (2010) Discussion > Recast PLL with actors from different de...

Recast PLL with actors from different decades...

posted 8 years ago by BLightyear
6 replies | jump to latest

80s
Alison - Michelle Pfeiffer
Spencer - Carrie Fisher
Aria - Winona Ryder
Emily - Demi Moore
Hanna - Jennifer Aniston
Ezra - Patrick Swayze?
Toby - Christian Slater
Caleb - Johnny Depp
Mona - Ally Sheedy

90s
Alison - Sarah Michelle Gellar
Spencer - Claire Danes
Aria - Mila Kunis
Emily - Neve Campbell
Hanna - Christina Applegate
Ezra - Matt Dillon
Toby - James Franco
Caleb - Heath Ledger
Mona - Christina Ricci

2000s
Alison - Rachel McAdams
Spencer - Lacey Chabert
Aria - Rachel Bilson
Emily - Mary Elizabeth Winstead
Hanna - Blake Lively
Ezra - Freddie Prinze Jr.
Toby - Chad Michael Murray
Caleb - Jared Padalecki
Mona - Michelle Trachtenberg

You have no idea how much thought I put into this LOL. And I struggled with every decade. I think I've made some bad choices.

[–] BLightyear 8 years ago

Bump.

[–] amity529 8 years ago

I don't know too many 80's actors but I'll do the other two decades.

90's

Alison - Rose McGowan
Spencer - Jennifer Love Hewitt
Aria - Sarah Michelle Gellar
Emily - Neve Campbell
Hanna - Christina Applegate
Ezra - Timothy Olyphant
Toby - Matthew Lillard
Caleb - Skeet Ulrich
Mona - Mila Kunis

2000's

Alison - Hayden Panetierre
Spencer - Michelle Tratchenburg
Aria - Miley Cyrus
Emily - Amanda Bynes
Hanna - Aly Michalka
Ezra - Jerry Trainor
Toby - Matthew Gray Gubler
Caleb - Josh Peck
Mona - Lauren London

[–] birdsbirdsbirds 8 years ago

Great idea! I love the 1980's so I'll try that:

80s
Alison - Daryl Hannah
Spencer - Laura Dern
Aria - Sarah Jessica Parker
Emily - Erica Gimpel
Hanna - Kim Richards
Ezra - Andrew McCarthy
Toby - Christian Slater
Caleb - Rob Lowe
Mona - Sherilyn Fenn

[–] BLightyear 8 years ago

Sarah Jessica Parker would make a more likable Aria! I love Laura Dern, but she'd certainly be a different take of Spencer, one that is softer. And that is one hot Mona!

[–] sunsoph-66636 8 years ago

80s
Alison - Brittany Daniel
Spencer - Kristin Davis
Aria - Neve Campbell
Emily - Alyssa Milano
Hanna - Jennifer Aniston
Ezra - ?
Toby - ?
Caleb - Scott Wolf
Mona - Shannen Doherty

90s
Alison - Jodie Seetin
Spencer - Jessica Biel
Aria - Shiri Appleby
Emily - Laura Preppon
Hanna - Michelle Williams
Ezra - Kerr Smith
Toby - Jason Behr
Caleb - Joshua Jackson
Mona - Jessica Alba

2000s
Alison - Sophia Bush
Spencer - Alexis Bledel
Aria - Katie Cassidy
Emily - Kaley Cuoco
Hanna - Blake Lively
Ezra - Jensen Ackles
Toby - James Lafferty
Caleb - Adam Brody
Mona - Nina Dobrev

[–] BLightyear 8 years ago

I would be really interesting to see Brody as Caleb. I could just imagine it.