MovieChat Forums > Man on a Ledge (2012) Discussion > dumbness: picture in front of camera

dumbness: picture in front of camera


putting a picture in front of a camera would NOT work: 1) field of view would not be identical to the real image, and worse, 2) the picture would not be in focus as those video camera lenses are set for a distance of several feet, if not infinity.

reply

Exactly what I thought at that scene

reply

It doesn't matter because without a light shining on the photo the camera would just display a black image.



I want to kill everyone. Satan is good. Satan is our pal.

reply

[deleted]

But if a guard was watching they'd see a picture cover the image they were looking at. It's ridiculous, come on.

reply

lol - I thought it was straight out of the Roadrunner school of logic.

reply

The a team actually lol

reply

[deleted]

They could've gone up to the vault, drawn a door on it, and opened the door.

reply

1. is not a valid complaint because you can match the FOV.

2. would be a valid complaint if you are a security camera expert. Most people I think will accept the idea that maybe the camera is auto-focusing. Maybe they do auto-focus in real life too.

http://www.maxloh.com/soundtracks/
http://smptv.net/student.php?id=101

reply

Yeah, I agree, maxloh.
Obviously to actually do this in real life would be very difficult and require careful testing. But for the purposes of a movie, I think the vast majority of the audience is willing to suspend their disbelief the little bit required for this event.

___
Thor Trek 2: Into the Dark World
Starring Chris Hemsworth as Thor, the father of Captain Kirk

reply

Yeah, this entire film was essentially implausible (I still found it fun, if easily forgettable), so I felt that scene fit right in with all the other circumstances that took place.

reply

Best fake-out of a security camera I've ever seen in film was in Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol. Although the technology used was pure fantasy, it was very clever nonetheless.

reply

Why are you analysing this to the death? Just sit back, relax and enjoy the FICTIONAL work known as a MOVIE.

_________________________________
Steven Seagal Fan Club President

reply

Well, the world moves and cheap tricks like this won't do anymore. Everyone with a webcam knows better.

It's a valid and reasonable critique.

reply

Are you telling me that Bugs Bunny doesn't really talk?

Are movies not real?

Who can you trust these days?

reply