MovieChat Forums > Silo (2023) Discussion > sci-fi/post-apo flavoured slow "who did ...

sci-fi/post-apo flavoured slow "who did it" conspiracy drama.


Intro is amazing
Music is climatic and great
Scenes and sets are truly truly truly great
Characters, for the most part, are quite great
Action was pretty bad. Director couldn't make it gripping and interesting.
Plot is basic and feels like characters get where they are supposed to be simply because script told them so. Also it's very slow to unravel.
There are alot and i mean ALOT of flashbacks. Some are okay and are supposed to add to the character, but some add "a bit too much", making it feel like it breaks what characters should know in the present time.. Plothole'ish.
Show does have other visible plotholes. They arent big, but those things are easy'ish to spot and should have been adressed.

What's interesting, the show doesn't mind killing big characters. Feels refreshing.

With just that it'd be really okay show to kill your free time. But there's 1 more thing. A dealbreaker for me.

It's ideolo/woke charged. I can't stand indoctrination. At first i thought it was just some minor character flaws, or "tough world" that shaped those people bit more roughly.. But i don't think that's the case anymore. I think director tries to play "gender war", where positive aspects are more likely to be bestowed on female characters, while negative on the males. Strenghts? Smarts? Ingenuity? You got plenty of that on one side. On the other we have incompetency, fear, lies, weakness, evilness for the sake of it. The only woman that could have been considered evil, or just powerhungry... turns out to be a poor crying victim of an evil man. Yawn.

Eitherway: if you can turn off critical thinking, or thinking in general, and don't mind ideolo, it's worth a watch.

[came to this forum out of frustration with imdb censorship.]

reply

[came to this forum out of frustration with imdb censorship.]

Yeah funny that.
Well you'll be in good company , this forum with its liberal (pun intended) approach to censorship has many plenty of refugees from other more strict sites who are outraged whenever they see a woman or black man on the screen - or indeed a white man who is not being the hero.

You'll spot a thread about it in pretty much every page here .
Although your inaugral post's 2nd paragraph rant ,despite being lengthy and well composed didnt score too highly on my "outraged antiwokie" bingo card , you didnt say
agenda
propaganda
box ticking

reply

"refugees from other more strict sites who are outraged whenever they see a woman or black man on the screen - or indeed a white man who is not being the hero."

Come on.. You just try to besmear others. By saying that you try to tag me as part of the group. That's lame.

Also, trying to joke about movies having agendas, propagandas and are woke just makes you look like CNN NPC.

reply