MovieChat Forums > The Way (2010) Discussion > Question for Catholics

Question for Catholics


Isn't it against the teachings of Catholicism to spread ashes? I thought ashes could only be buried in consecrated ground, yet Sheen spreads his son's ashes throughout the pilgrimage.

reply

The Catholic Church apparently thinks spreading ashes or keeping them in your home in an urn isn't reverent. I an a fallen away Catholic, both my parents were cremated and interred on their parish grounds, but you must remember that most of these rules are man-made. It is the Church's position, but I say if you want to talk to mom and dad in front of the fireplace, who in the heck are they to say you can't. After all the wrong the Church has done, I am not shaking in my boots about breaking a rule here or there.

"If I were any closer to you, I'd be in back of you"

reply

Church has set up many man-made rules which supposedly take you closer to salvation (thought I think they are strategically planned its own interest). But Catholicism also preaches repentance, forgivenness and not being judgemental. Which means that if you do not follow their rules, only God will judge you and nobody can tell how he will judge you. I believe that being faithfull to your instinct makes this world a better place.

reply

Church has set up many man-made rules which supposedly take you closer to salvation (thought I think they are strategically planned its own interest). But Catholicism also preaches repentance, forgivenness and not being judgemental. Which means that if you do not follow their rules, only God will judge you and nobody can tell how he will judge you. I believe that being faithfull to your instinct makes this world a better place.

reply

most of these rules are man-made
They all are.

What can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence.

reply

Yes, the Doctrine of the Church allows cremation and, out of respect for the body (temple) in which the Holy Spirit dwelt, does not allow the spreading of ashes. Since Tom is a fallen-away Catholic, it could be that he isn't familiar with the teachings of the Church.

reply

Tom was a lapsed Catholic, he said so himself, so he doesn't care what the Catholic Church says is the way to do things, and I say good for him.

I also agree all this stuff is man-made rules.

reply

The real question is, what would Emilio have wanted? If he had remarked that he wanted to be buried/interred in some other way or in some other place (perhaps in the same place as his mother), Martin doesn't have the right to decide. I didn't sit through this film start to finish...

reply