MovieChat Forums > Jigeum uri hakgyoneun (2022) Discussion > High school students assigned janitorial...

High school students assigned janitorial duties?


Is it a punishment?

reply

Can't speak to Korea but it's normal in Japan. Not as a punishment, just to teach them that it has to be done.

With the labor shortage caused by pandemic policies, some US schools are paying high school kids to be janitors. Which probably isn't a bad idea. I would have loved to skip the commute to my afterschool job.

reply

kinda is. if your schooling is so underfunded you cant afford janitors, but can blow trillions on the military and private prisons and many of the top corporations paying zero tax

Yet going to have the poor kids work cause its cheaper labor than paying an adult (any guesses how many of the rich kids will be doing this job?) your country is fucked up.

Americans need to see the world. NOTHING is normal about American society. Japan may have a cultural reason having EVERY kid do it I agree with. having the poor kids do it cause schools are underfunded is fucked up

reply

No. People were afraid to work. We had shots that lower the risk of the virus to the seasonal flu. All the money in the world wouldn't fix such an irrational fear.

And the kids were still paid union wages, anyway. I was not better off as a poor kid without that opportunity.

reply

https://livelearnventure.com/korean-education-and-the-korean-classroom/

"In South Korea, it’s common for students to clean the classrooms and other areas in the school. This includes cleaning tasks such as taking out the trash, vacuuming, and sweeping. My thoughts are that this is in place to teach students to take responsibility and treat their classrooms and school areas with respect.

Students are assigned certain tasks. Everyday after lunch, alejandroescamilla-bookstudents come to our English Town to clean. In the United States, I’ve heard of teachers assigning certain responsibilities such as collecting homework or being a line leader, but I’m not sure I can see as much student cleaning going over as well back home."

"The Korean school constituency takes student accountability seriously. School identifications also means school chores. Students set up the classroom and attend to the proxemics of the chairs, desks, and what ever else is needed. Student teams rotate, sweeping and mopping their classroom, hallways, and bathrooms daily. I am not sure whether students are involved on a daily or weekly basis with throwing out the trash or window cleaning. Students generally erase all chalkboards, white boards, and often dust. Student teams clean the toilets, sinks, counters, and sometimes, the mirrors. Students are expected to self-monitor, follow a schedule, cultivate a sense of student dependability, and standards of basic sanitation."

reply

America really needs to adopt this, because kids in America are unruly, irresponsible, unclean, and filthy. They carry this mentality right out into the general public where they litter and keep the streets stained with rubbish.

*sigh*

Shame we can't overhaul the Western school system to mirror those in South Korea, Japan, and Singapore. Maybe it might spell a brighter, cleaner future for Western society.

reply

No. It's called responsibility.

reply

And free labor. Brilliant way to keep the school clean. Nobody is going to graffiti the school when mullet douche is on cleaning duty.

reply

Lol. I don't get why the mullet is back and popular again.

reply

It works for the character.

reply

no its called having the poor kids do it so you can pay less wages than an adult wouldn't.

reply