MovieChat Forums > Inception (2010) Discussion > Cobb is in reality at the end of the mov...

Cobb is in reality at the end of the movie


If you remember from the scene where Ariadne goes into Cobb's dream and he's at the dream/memory of wanting to call out to the children before he leaves since their backs are turned; every time the projections of the children show up they are always with their backs turned, until the end of the movie when he goes home and finally sees their faces; the top was never Cobb's totem, as he even said, it just acted as a placeholder until he could see his children's faces again, which he does at the end, meaning that Cobb is back in the real world.

reply

Cobb is a dude who became mentally unbalanced, following the loss of his wife - either she slept with another dude, or she died, or she simply left him, because he kept failing to bring home the Oscar.

He lives in a delusional reality he concocted inside his disturbed mind, where he's an agent who can enter other people's minds, via a rubber cord coming out of a suitcase, that he straps around his arm. The guilt he experiences from being unable to prevent the loss of his wife, manifests as paranoia - government agents and occult organizations assassins out there tryin to get him.

The cold baths that his psychiatrists administer him, to take him out of the episodic deliriums he sinks into, he sees them as ways of getting out of "dream levels".
His father finally finds the right psychotherapist for him, in the person of what Cobbs sees as "student architect", who knows how to build "labyrinths". Like you need to be an architect, to build a labyrinth...
Ariadne helps him in one last "heist", where she incidentally helps him throw Mal, the very wife he loves, out the window.
Then he wakes up in the "real world", like from a terrible "dream", and no more occult organization assassins tryin to get him, no more government agents chasin him around the world.

The poor guy comes home to his children, and spins a shtoopid top, that he was unable to spin before throughout the movie.

The spinning top maintains balance. So is the subject's mind maintaining balance. Cobb's pop thanks the psychotherapist for a job well done. But Nolan cut that part from the movie, he needs monies, and nobody would see this movie twice, if they'd figure what da faq is it about.

Inception is a remake of Hitchcock's Vertigo.

reply

There's multiple different theories out there that can counter yours. I mean MANY. So sorry, this doesn't really prove anything

reply

I thought it was obvious the ending was real. Why would he accept a life with kids that aren't real.
He let the Mal projection go, because she wasn't good enough. He spends the entire film finding a way to get to his real kids..

By the beard of Zeus!

reply

nolan is to straight forward a director to make make a movie were the entire film is a dream as for the ending it has to be real because the top wobbles theres no way around it

reply

The children do not have their backs turned because he is dreaming. They have their backs turned because Cobb is still in touch with reality enough to realize that if he looks at their faces, he will fall for the delusion. That's why when he is with Mal at the very deepest "dream layer" near the end of the film, he shields his eyes from looking at his children...which he does by the end of the film, because he ends up believing he is in reality.

The fact Cobb used the totem as a mere placeholder is evidence that from the beginning he already had placed faith in an element of reality that was merely within his giant dream, which is why he ended up looking at his children's faces.

Someone else talked about the top wobbling back and forth. I hate to break it to them and anyone else, but the wobbling is not ample evidence that it ends up toppling over. It merely comforts the audience so they won't have to ask anymore questions. The shot does not remain on the top long enough to show us that the top's wobbling becomes increasingly more drastic and intense as it would before toppling. We simply see it begin to wobble.

reply

you can see the totem was beginning to lose momentum before the camera cut , so it's real

also notice the wedding ring on Cobb !! , he has it in dreams but never in the real world !! and he didn't have it in the end

reply

The totem, never wobbles any other time though. It always spins perfect.


By the beard of Zeus!

reply

Well, we only see the top spinning for very short times during the movie, so each time we could easily be seeing the top right after it has been spun, which would result in seeing minimal-to-no wobbling. At the end, the camera watches the top spinning for an extended period of time (and well after Cobb had spun it). So, we could be seeing the top at a different point from the other times during the film, and thus it's possible, even in a dream, it could wobble a little bit (it would just never fall). To me, that means the ending is still ambiguous.

"Game over, man! Game over!"

reply

There is no proof, no evidence, and there are no infallible arguments that Cobb is ever in the real world.

It's one of my all-time favorites, but come on people ... stop thinking you have the film figured out, because you don't. Everything is a theory. There are no right or wrong answers.

reply

You are right -- there are no infallible arguments. My opinion is that Cobb is in the real world because it makes the most sense for the story. I also believe that the symbology in the movie all points to Cobb escaping the trap of the resilient parasite.

The main theme of the movie is about the power of a simple idea to define and control you. Once established a simple idea is like a parasite or a virus, it becomes almost impossible to eradicate. A number of symbols represent this resilient parasite (ex. the Penrose steps.)

Another example is the use of mirrors. When Cobb looks in the mirror, he sees Mal. That makes he and Mal mirror characters -- a mirror image is not identical to the original. (If the original is right-handed, then the mirror is left-handed.) The infinite mirrors represent the resilient parasite of an idea. When one mirror is broken by Ariadne, this foreshadows her assistance of Cobb to cure him of his resilient parasite. It's the same thing with the Penrose steps or the train symbol.


👿 I know something you don't know ... I am ambidextrous!

reply

Looked like it was toppling at the end. Enough to suggest ambiguity.

...reifications are the shadows cast by the opacity of language

reply

you can see the totem was beginning to lose momentum before the camera cut , so it's real

also notice the wedding ring on Cobb !! , he has it in dreams but never in the real world !! and he didn't have it in the end


yes, the ring is the strongest clue to waking world or dreaming world. In fact you need look no further. the totem is unreliable to Cobb because it belonged to her, but he uses it anyway. his children are his totem.

when he leaves for Rome Philippa has blond hair and black shoes.
when he returns Philippa has brown hair and is taller and has on pink sneakers.

now you can argue all you want, but the director laid it out for you. When Cobb walks thru customs he is NOT wearing a wedding ring.

and yes the totem is falling as the camera pulls away. but the two other things I have mentioned are your real clues.
Nolan was interviewed and he mentioned these clues and they guy who plays the driver and provides the sedation also said what in the world would be the point of the whole movie if he doesn't get home for real and is still dreaming?

reply