MovieChat Forums > The Great Gatsby (2013) Discussion > Redford version was the best

Redford version was the best

posted 8 years ago by acriser15
3 replies | jump to latest

The one with Robert Redford was the best one in my opinion, anyone agree?

[–] octopusmagnificens 8 years ago

It would be unless Mia Farrow.

[–] catbookss 8 years ago

I thought Mia Farrow was a very good Daisy.

Too difficult for me to compare the two Gatsby versions and say one was superior to the other. One was quiet, the other raucous. I enjoyed them both for different reasons.

[–] foster11 8 years ago

Just saw the whole thing for the first time. and I'm with you

Redford was a better gatsby

Farrow as a better Daisey, I saw Daisey as a very cold person unless she was getting her own way, or in her own world. as such wouldn't have been crying at the drop of the hat

Tom was well played by both actors

Toby was OK but waterson was better.

You don't have to stand tall, but you do have to stand up!