At the house **SPOILER ALERT**

Same. It seems like there were times in the movie where they played it just this side of safe, which is a shame because the subject matter is about as dark as it gets. Might as well freak out your audience fully.

Same here. I mean, Penny said she was being slowly eaten alive, yet she seemed to only be missing part of one leg. So that seems like just once instance of butchering, no?

I was also confused when we saw him open the walk-in freezer and there were torsos and body parts everywhere in there.
But at the beginning of Noa's captivity, Steve says that the meat is best when it's fresh, which is why he takes it off of them while they're still alive, and why he keeps them alive throughout.
I mean, it shows us that he's had a lot of victims, but I feel like there are better ways of doing that that don't directly contradict an important aspect of the movie.