MovieChat Forums > Rampage (2010) Discussion > If you thought this was in any way reali...

If you thought this was in any way realistic, you're an idiot.


Honestly, I've never understood what people liked about this movie...the protagonist is unintentionally unlikeable and the scenarios are beyond contrived. Now, it's a movie...I understand people will overlook that but I hear some people actually saying this could happen and it's realistic and I have to say that is beyond obtuse. I've complied a list of glaring problems with this movie and why it's not at all realistic.

1. The suit.
Kevlar is a para-aramid synthetic fiber...it's designed specifically to absorb rounds not directly deflect them like they did in the movie. A material that did that would be extremely dense and thus extremely heavy. You'd probably be wearing panels of boron carbide, boron nitride or diamond...granted this may be possible but here's the problem...it would cost a fortune. Isn't this guy supposed to be strapped for cash at his very low paying job?

2. The explosives
Considering this has to be something that could demolish a building...Imagine it would have to be nitro-glycerine...could nitro-glycerine demolish a building the way it would used in the movie...no, it couldn't. But I'll concede that for a second and ask this question...how the *beep* is he affording this? Also, how did he acquire it? You can't just buy nitro-glycerine from a convenience store. Either way...that amount of explosive would cost a fortune! When you couple that with the suit...this starts to add up. (We haven't even gotten to the weapons yet)

3. The weapons
According to the wiki page for this movie...he used a Heckler & Koch MP7A1 submachine gun, a Ruger MP9 submachine gun, a Glock 17 semiautomatic pistol, a Beretta 92FS semiautomatic pistol and 2 combat knives...Now the average cost of all of these weapons would probably be around $8,000-$10,000...that's if he were lucky enough to order them on an auction site or something...and even then you'd have to give up very personal information...like your social security number, home address, etc. and a criminal background check....you could say he ordered them illegally but that would jack up the cost significantly. Considering all of the materials, he would need at least 5 years to set all this up...and that's with the kind of connections that could even allow for this to transpire. What about planning and the logistics involved...how long would that take? Probably another 1-2 years?

But quite frankly, when you have characters this conveniently stupid who needs planning and logistics...am I right?

4. The conveniently moronic police
Alright...lets say all the police were in that building that blew up...instead of course of the two beat cops in the strip mall. The cops confront Bill and ask him to surrender when he starts shooting at them...his magazines eventually runs out of rounds and he needs to reload. What do these cops do when he's reloading? Call for back-up (S.W.A.T, State Police, Sheriff's Dept, anyone)...No. They commence firing, while moving away from cover and inexplicably commanding Bill to "get down"...a few questions.

a.) Why are they moving away from cover?
b.) Why are they firing and giving commands...even if you want him to get down, how would expect him to hear you over the sound of your gun firing?

5. The conveniently stupid best friend
Evan is an idiot...there is no way around it...I mean what the hell was he doing the whole time...his friend enticed him to call out sick to work and when Evan does show up, Bill is no where to be found...so what did he do the whole day? Just twiddle his thumbs like an idiot?

6. The conveniently lazy coffee barista
Was there a reason he couldn't make the macchiato correctly? It's not like there was a line and honestly what would be the point in not correcting your mistake...what does the coffee barista/owner not like tips or customers?

7. The conveniently incompetent fast-food worker
One scene in particular pissed me off and was incredibly unrealistic...when the worker decides to start cleaning the table the two guys are eating on...if you've ever worked at a restaurant where you had to bus tables...you know why that was *beep*

8. The Sheriff's Department?
What the *beep* was taking them so long...they're supposed to keep in close contact with a dispatch relay. What the hell was dispatch doing?

9. The town's conveniently arrogant and stupid townsfolk.
Salon scene was incredibly stupid but that paled in comparison to the stupidity of the bingo hall scene and how no one decides to call the authorities. But then again one guy came through...he blows up a police station, kills dozens of people in broad daylight, kills 3 armed men, robs a bank, blows up two squad cars and gets away with it? *beep*, imagine if there were two of these guys...hell they could've killed everyone in town, robbed the town blind and fled before 3pm.

10. The premise and why the movie's point is a complete fail.
The reason Bill Williamson gives for why he did all this was overpopulation...yet there isn't a single theme that suggest that was problem and even worse it takes place in a small town! If there is one thing a small town doesn't traditionally have...it's a population problem!

I could go on and on about this movie...

reply

The best part is how butt hurt you are over a movie.

reply

The best part is how butt hurt you are over a movie.


It's not necessarily that I'm butt hurt...it's that I can't fathom the level of idiocy it would take for a functioning adult to find this remotely realistic or even good. I mean before being a pompous *beep* maybe you should've read the title of the thread...I mean suspension of disbelief is one thing...this film is asking us to suspend insanity.

reply

You are hilarious! You call people idiots and name call like a child.

Anders Breivik pulled off a killing spree eerily similar. Minus the suit of armour.

Have fun being so mad about a movie!

reply

You are hilarious! You call people idiots and name call like a child.


Coincidentally, you have the cognitive abilities of a child. The level of stupidity this film displays is apparently not discernible to you.

Anders Breivik pulled off a killing spree eerily similar. Minus the suit of armour.


Eerily similar? We certainly have a differing definition of: similar

Anders Breivik's attacks took place in Norway's most populated city, Oslo...and a remote island Utøya which harbored mostly children...the attack which left 77 dead, with 69 killed on the island, 33 of whom were under the age of 18...all unarmed...as opposed to the protagonist who's attacks took place in an apparently small town in the United States where typically everyone is armed.

Andres Breivik didn't decimate an entire police station with a nitroglycerin encapsulated van that he could control remotely...which the way it was done in the film would be virtually impossible. The demolition of a building doesn't occur that way.

Andres Breivik didn't successfully rob a bank single-handily...after demolishing a police station and killing a plethora of people in broad daylight.

Anders Breivik formulated and financed his plan for a little less than a decade as opposed to the protagonist who either did this impulsively or in a premeditated fashion in the span of less than three years...it couldn't have been more than that considering the series of events that led up to the "rampage."

After 9 years manning a lucrative enterprise Andres Breivik wasn't able whatsoever to thwart the authorities...whereas this macchiato drinking protagonist was able to do it with relative ease.

Bill Williamson was not only able to destroy a police station, murder a substantial amount of people in broad daylight, kill a group of women in a salon who were inexplicably talking trash about him after he left initially instead of attempting to call the cops, play a game of "Bingo" with some elderly people, obliterate 2 cop cars and frame his conveniently stupid and oblivious friend who coincidentally never questions why the friend he ditched work for never showed up for paintball...not only that but he gets away with it...Andres Breivik was apprehended minutes after the attacks on Utøya and virtually got an indefinite sentence in prison.

Have fun being so mad about a movie!


I'm not mad about the movie...my indignation comes from its apparent popularity amongst a cult following...How can a film with such superfluous character development (Bill's tribulations are irrelevant considering the plot), plot holes galore, conveniently stupid characters, and writing that displays how blithely disconnected the director is to reality...be so popular amongst any functioning adult. It's flabbergasting.

reply

Good God it took you months to pull together that sad rambling response!

You should like get a hobby. I forgot all about this forum post until just know.

I bet people hate living and being around you.

reply

Good God it took you months to pull together that sad rambling response!


No, I just so happened to read your response months afterward and decided to leave a response to that response.

You should like get a hobby.


I already do...watching movies, occasionally critiquing them.

I forgot all about this forum post until just know.


So did I...but I see you still have incredibly poor taste.

I bet people hate living and being around you.


Well no...I beloved by everyone that knows me. By the way, how is that relevant to anything?

reply

I don't think anyone takes you seriously.

reply

[deleted]

Like you say yourself; It IS a movie.

Even if people would say it could happen, I'm sure it's not them thinking the MOVIE is "true to life" accurate. I mean - we already know that a huge shootout where several armed police officers are given a whole TON of trouble by two heavily armored guys with automatic weapons CAN happen, as it has actually happened. Sure, that case lead to both of the armored men dying, but WITH budget, with preparation, with the right kind of combined armors... It's plausible that even one person could manage a whole ton of *beep*

We know that cars can be remote controller - we know that explosives and detonators exist... that makes the steerable car bomb part plausible aswell.

To manage to get away with it all? That's the most unbelievable part in the movie, yet it's not exactly unheard of either that people could be fooled or framed.


Either way... just a movie. To go to lenghts like you have to analyze every part that far and that accurately... I personally think it's a waste of your time :/

Especially pointless waste of time, if you didn't even like the movie.

reply

LOL! It's a movie. If you want real life it's all around you. Movies are mostly FICTION and DRAMA.

I thought the movie was really good and quite believable. Uwe Boll finally earned his oxygen in my books.

reply