MovieChat Forums > Sex and the City 2 (2010) Discussion > SAMANTHA did NOT say that CHARLOTTE!!!!

SAMANTHA did NOT say that CHARLOTTE!!!!


remember at the beginning of the movie after the wedding the girls were having lunch and they met Erin, the nanny and Samantha GAWKED over the Nanny being hot and her boobs blasting and said "THERE OUGHT TO BE A LAW ON HAVING A NANNY WHO LOOKS LIKE THAT" and then Carrie continued saying "YEAH THE JUDE LAW" and they all laughed... and then from then on Charlotte started being sketchy about Erin being alone with Harry?

Ok yes, Sam brought up how hot the nanny was but who wouldn't? geez, ...sam NEVER SAID... hey charlotte you should feel threatened by erin , harry's going to cheat on you.


So later on in the movie when Miranda and Char were having a mothers bonding moment at their dinner and Charlotte confessed "remember when Samantha said that Harry was going to cheat on me with the nanny? well the first thing I thought was ...NO NOT THE NANNY!" and it was hardy har har funny or whatver?

WELL CHARLOTTE...... AND SATC WRITERS ..... get your sh!t straight. SAMANTHA SAID NO SUCH THING! I mean charlotte even tried to quote what Samantha said and Sam didnt say that. Her head is the one that spun that thought out of control in that way and now its all Sams fault.

Sam talks real talk. she says things as she sees them. Seeing a hot nanny come running toward their table with bouncing, jiggling, perfect boobs with no bra in her face and then NOT say anything or even JOKE with one of your best friends of a million years about their nanny would BE FAKE as all hell. What so once Erin walked away Sam shouldnt be who sam is and call it like it is? Please anyone would of said "damn shes hot." But the rest of the crap was spun from charlottes head. Yes maybe Sam insinuated about "having a law about having a nanny like that" in a way like " yeah there should be laws because it might distract the household bc everyones staring at her boobies all tha time" or whatver... but Sam did not say "harry is gonna cheat on you" or anything of that nature. IF ANYTHING it was stupid ass Carries comment "yea the jude law" that MADE THAT KIND OF THINKING go into charlottes head.Jude Law cheated on his wife with the nanny. So point blank , CARRIE is the one that planted that idea in Charlottes head. Whatevr, I know im heated over this, but it fuggin always bugged me about this. quit pointing the finger at Sam. ughhh

reply

I agree with you. Screenwriters mistake, indeed. The conversation between Charlotte and Miranda should point Carrie's little "joke".

Please excuse my terrible redaction, english is not my native language.

reply

Well that's always been SATC's way - Carrie is never in the wrong, no matter how selfish, careless, sarcastic or inconsiderate she is, she's always portrayed in a good light.

Especially in this one she's just horrible to Charlotte.

reply

Yes, you are right! Carrie was the one who made the joke, yet Charlotte overlooked that and put words in Samantha's mouth. This isn't the first time either. Remember in the series when Charlotte's brother was coming to visit her and she was talking to the girls about his marriage? All three of them made fun of "Wesley and Leslie", Carrie the most, yet Charlotte only seemed to be bothered by Miranda and Samantha's comments.

reply

♥ your post-it profile picture!!

Maria: I look like a slut. Ariel: But a nice slut.
~~ Grumpier Old Men

reply

Yeah, because Samantha's comment had absolutely no blatant and strong implication to it at all...

When you're 17 a cow can seem dangerous and forbidden...am I alone here?

reply