MovieChat Forums > Womb (2011) Discussion > Theodore Sturgeon story???

Theodore Sturgeon story???


Though the information is sketchy at best and the completed film may be totally unlike it, is it based on Theodore Sturgeon's 1962 story "When You Care, When You Love"?

reply

Unfortunately not.

I'm a huge Sturgeon fan, and now that censorship has relaxed I would like to see an adaptation of his "unfilmable" book Some of Your Blood. Now that would be a challenge.

"Three quarters of what is said here can be completely discounted as the raving of imbeciles" - Donald Wolfit in Blood of the Vampire (1958)

Ditto, Colin Wilson's Lingard.

reply

Why would this be unfilmable?

reply

Some of Your Blood is a murder mystery about a protagonist addicted to slurping menstrual blood -directly from the woman. Even in these days of morbid horror films and increasingly clinical TV series of the CSI persuasion, having the protagonist and central theme of a movie based on this subject would not play. Sturgeon's leaving it to one's imagination is why the novel is fascinating and compelling.

In Colin Wilson's case, I thought he went one step further in having LINGARD a burglar and thrill killer as protagonist. In Colin's book, the story is strictly first person and you are made not merely to sympathize with the awful and repugnant (in a normal sense) "hero" but virtually encouraged to get off on his antics. The same approach was taken by Sturgeon, where we are not supposed to be repelled by the kinky "hero"'s fetish, but once the novelty wears off to be theoretically turned on.

I've seen several porno films that take this sort of tack, you know, identifying and rooting for the rapist is a common example, but they are strictly porn, usually XXX, and often just aimed at fetishists, the way the thousands of bondage videos that are cranked out every year are. I meant as a real film, for real theatrical audiences, not mere pornography, both Sturgeon and Wilson have created unique novels that would be inappropriate to turn into concrete visuals. It could be done badly or stupidly, but who needs another bad or stupid movie, when hundreds of big-budget one falling into those categories are routinely released every year?

reply