MovieChat Forums > Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024) Discussion > Praetorian Jack was a better Mad Max tha...

Praetorian Jack was a better Mad Max than Tom Hardy was


Not only did Tom Burke look more like Mel Gibson than Tom Hardy did, but the character was portrayed in a manner much more akin to what I expected/would've preferred Max to be in Fury Road.

I understand that it was their intent to make Max more animalistic and feral than he's ever been in that film, but the way Hardy portrayed him with that weird accent and overly gruff voice, made him seem far too removed from the Max of the original trilogy IMO. Even after the Max of that film supposedly regains his humanity towards the end, Hardy still speaks with that caveman-like grunt.

Praetorian Jack on the other hand, while also a tough, no-nonsense badass, also had traces of charisma and charm to him which made him feel much more akin to Mel Gibson's Max. He's the character we should've seen onscreen at a certain point in Fury Road when Max begins becoming more accepting of the group of women he's helping, yet is nowhere near present in the actual film. Hell, even the clothes Praetorian Jack wore seems more in line with what Max wore in the first two films than what Hardy wore.

Who's with me?

reply

I agree with you. I didn't like this film and no one can replace Mel Gibson as Max but that actor definetly had more Max vibes than Tom Hardy. I noticed it immediately.

Nothing Tom Hardy's Max did in Fury Road, even the things he said, reminded me of Mad Max. He was a grunting neanderthal who weirdly when he did manage to form a coherent sentence talked about things like finding redemption which I can't imagine Gibson's Max saying.

reply

Man, this is spot on. I hadn't considered this nor thought about it this way, but now that you mention it, the light bulb has come on.

reply

Big fan of Fury Road here but yeah, it looks like they went with the wrong Tom a decade ago.

reply