MovieChat Forums > Cracks (2011) Discussion > The book. ( This may contain spoilers )

The book. ( This may contain spoilers )


Are there allot of changes from the book?

like fiamma not having blond hair, there isn't a characters named poppy either and of course that she is from Spain instead of Italy.

__________________________________

how'd you like to love me forever

reply

The story takes place in England, not South Africa, and is set in the '30s (not the '50s). Some characters appear to have been excluded, while others have been added (Poppy, Lily, Laurel). Minor details include different hair colours for Di and Fiamma, and things of that nature. I have a feeling that Miss G. will be presented as more feminine and deceptive.


---------
Earn Amazon, Starbucks, and other GCs via search:

http://abe5.com/bxv

reply

SPOILERSS!!







Does this also contain the disturbing murder scene?

__________________________________

how'd you like to love me forever

reply

The murder scene isn't as depicted in the book - no abuse with sticks in body. The girls hit her with sticks though it's due to Miss G's actions that Fiamma dies.

----------------
We are the angry mob...

reply

ah good... i really don't need a visual with what happened in the book. they can't do such scene's in movies anyway, certainly not when its about under aged girls.

__________________________________

how'd you like to love me forever

reply

I'm actually glad that the murder scene isn't straight out of the book, that was hard to read....

Hope it comes to the US soon?....

Remember, remember, the Fifth of November...

reply


Haven't read the book, what's the difference between the death scenes? Is it too ghastly?
________________________________

Obadiah Obadiah, Jah Jah sent us here to catch vampire

reply

The book is far more haunting, as you read the entire thing believing that Fiamma merely disappeared one day, never to be seen again!

The book starts out with a re-union of all the girls, who are grown women now.

In the book, it's a SWIM team that actually competes with other schools, but in the film version they're a DIVING team that only competes with eachother.

Also, as has already been mentioned, in the book they're in South Africa, not England; and Fiamma is Italian, not Spanish. Also, the other girls in the book are more clearly defined. In the film, it's only Di, Fiamma, and Fuzzy from the book, with new girls created (like Poppy).

The casting for the film was outstanding, especially Miss G, Fiamma, and Di!

Also, in the book, Miss G isn't particularly EVIL. Yes, she's infatuated with Fiamma, but she has nothing whatsoever to do with the girl's final demise.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

What about the ending in the book? They sodomized her with sticks!?!?!?

reply

Yes, she's infatuated with Fiamma, but she has nothing whatsoever to do with the girl's final demise.


How interesting! Does Miss G have no role whatsoever in the book? In the movie it is clear that she manipulated the students to persecute Fiamma, as it is clear that she kills her. In the book, what is the incentive for the students to chase after Fiamma, beat her up and sodomize her? What is Fiamma's "demise", and how does the book explain her disappearance (if it does)? Does Fiamma die in the book?


reply

I think they should have left it in South Africa. It would have played better. Also, left the character as Italian. Don't get the changes.

reply