The Ending is Terrible


First of all, what a film. Absolutely loved it up until the "twist" ending. The buildup was brilliant! My girlfriend who hates generic Hollywood films (she did Film at University) was genuinely on the edge of her seat during any of the scenes where tension is building and was very much on the side of "what the *beep* is going on?" Which made the film interesting and compelling. Along with John Goodmans acting the film was turning out to be a 9/10...then the ending came...what the *beep* was that ending all about.

It's literally like the writers sat down and went "What's going to happen when she goes outside? We can't have the Cloverfield monster appear as it'd be too obvious to Cloverfield fans and an attack by a foreign nation is too boring...what shall we do???....Aliens!"

Which was a terrible decision, they either should have stuck to the whole Cloverfield monster thing OR have her escape with Howard still alive and the underground bunker still intact. She escapes in her suit and see's the world turned to chaos due to the devastation left after the Nuclear Attack against Clovie, realises (through visual imagery) that her only current choice is to essentially become Howards weird "adoptive" child (he behaved more like a man who wanted a daughter rather than a sex slave) or sex slave. Then have Howard come back and begin to drag her in as the camera pans out showing just how much devastation the attack on Clovie caused, then another "roar" from Clovie to again give us the "is Clovie alive or dead" mystery. I very much wanted the end (especially after I saw the actual ending) to be a "This is what the world is now, accept it or die".

Instead we have *beep* aliens who have the ability to fly yet can't chase a slower, weaker female human down, have trouble against plastic bottles, display their weakest spot for the human to take advantage of & get tricked by a *beep* car alarm. Just more *beep* dumb aliens vs lucky human, seen it dozens of times...IT'S BORING. As soon as the aliens appear, you know she isn't going to die, you know there is going to be some freedom fighter movement against the aliens, you know all of this as soon as the movie confirms the threat.

Plus the after-scene was so *beep* She's driving along and has to make a decision between

Route A = Literally nothing
Route B = People that will help you but you might to help them &/or fight Aliens

Woah what a *beep* of a decision that one must have been...god I can tell why she has such difficulty making that decision.

It had a very "I Am Legend" quality ending to me and that was *beep* as well. It had the standard "nothing bad can happen to the protraganist so she won't die and there's a solution provided to all her problems" *beep*

Final result: 5/10 (You can skip the ending and pretend they all remain friends in the bunker, that'd be a better ending)

reply

Totally agreed!

I loved this film through the moment she saw the birds and took off the mask to breath. I was loving it, wondering what was going to happen.

And then a UFO and a weird alien dog thingie?

WHAT?

From that moment on I couldn't take the scrunched "WTF is this crap" look off my face. Just completely misplaced.

reply

Oh god yeah.

It's all very good until that final 20 seconds.

I mean, please... am I supposed to to swoon and think "my heroin"?

reply

Oh you have a problem with the monster?

I thought was really cool.

reply

The twist was epic! It was all true.

reply

totally agree with you

reply

I liked it. Honestly, I liked the twist ending also, mainly because you end up thinking he's just nuts and a killer, which he is, but then, the outside situation is ...well, worse.

I was genuinely surprised, but the name of the movie did make me think at one point about Cloverfield....but I still enjoyed this.

reply

I sorta agree with you. The ending had me feel that the Studio, not just the writers, felt compelled to make this about an apocalyptic/zombie/aliens attack as this genre has been getting a lot of financing these past several years. The captivity plot carried more weight and character development and you could honestly tie in their story-line with the one from The Road with Viggo Mortenson.

reply

And she has a choice to go north to a "safe zone" or west to Houston to fight aliens.The only reason she went outside was to avoid getting doused in acid by Goodman.Yeah right,she's gonna go fight aliens! She could've broken a fingernail. You go girl!

reply