MovieChat Forums > All Good Things (2010) Discussion > How much truth is there to this movie?

How much truth is there to this movie?


I read up on David Marks aka Robert Durst, and I am wondering how much of this movie is just guess work?

The only thing we know for sure is that Katie disappeared, Robert killed Malvern Bump (aka Morris Black) in self defense and that Deborah Lehrman (aka Susan Berman), was murdered execution style.

The whole movie insinuates that David had a hand in all of this, but did the real David, aka Robert do all of that?

Is it like we all know that OJ Simpson killed his wife and her lover, but we can't prove it?

reply

You are correct. We don't know for sure if Durst killed Kathie. It would be VERY likely, however. This family had so much money and power behind them, but barely did anything to try and help find Kathie. Robert did kill Morris Black in "self-defense". But the fact that he never told the police makes it incredibly odd. He was only given 8 or 9 months in prison for improper disposal of a body. And yes, Susan Berman was murdered execution style just before she was going to be questioned about Kathie's disappearance. No one has been convicted of the murder.

Is Robert not as guilty as we think? I'm not sure. I think, however, the fact that his name is tied to all of these events, is very suspicious. I personally believe that he killed his wife, especially since his family did very little to try and find her. I also think it's crazy how he was only sentenced to less than a year in prison for burying a body that he killed and not telling a single soul about it. It may as well been in self defense, but that doesn't excuse the fact that he buried the body himself and didn't tell anyone. That makes him even more guilty in my book.

With Susan Berman, we have no idea if Robert was involved or not. That may as well just of been a coincidence.

Either way, I think that Durst is guiltier than he has been proven to be. And yes, we just can't prove it.


FYC: Best Supporting Actress
http://i56.tinypic.com/vh5l35.jpg

reply

I agree, it is all very suspicious that Robert's name is tied to all of the events.

I think he got off so light on the improper disposal of a body due to his family name and I'm sure a very well payed Lawyer.

reply

Only the broad strokes are true. Most everything else they changed, or just plain made up.

reply

Can you provide some examples?

reply

[deleted]


How would they know Susan B was masquerading as Katie?

I really liked this film but there were a few things I didn't get. Also, what was it that Kadie found covered in blood right before she disappeared?


- Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine

reply

Also, what was it that Kadie found covered in blood right before she disappeared?
The bandanna that used to be tied around the dog's neck.


reply

-> How would they know Susan B was masquerading as Katie?

There's some info on this website: http://archives.lasvegascitylife.com/articles/2004/02/25/cover_story/cover.txt

"The dean of Kathleen Durst's college told investigators that a woman identifying herself as Kathleen called in sick to school around the time of her disappearance. Friends and family believe Berman made that call."

I guess if a few people thought that Susan was helping Durst with his alibi, then it would make sense she would pose as Kathleen.

reply

If you don't have evidence, why do you think that? Pure prejudice I guess. We don't know what we can't prove - that's why courts require proof.

Besides, you're taking your facts from the movie. He didn't serve 9 months for improper disposal of a body - he served about 3 years on a variety of charges.


"I'll book you. I'll book you on something. I'll find something in the book to book you on."

reply

The factual reporting, that is the text that appears overlaid in the movie, is based on facts. The 2 prosecutions, one in New York and one and Texas, that is true. Also the conviction in Texas and the fact the case is outstanding in New York and classified as a "missing persons" case.

There are no problems that cannot be solved with a can of brake clean and a lighter

reply

"I am wondering how much of this movie is just guess work? "

None of it. The entire movie is true.

"but did the real David, aka Robert do all of that? "

Yes.

"The only thing we know for sure is..."

You didn't watch the movie? We know a lot more than that.

reply