MovieChat Forums > Orphan (2009) Discussion > Who Guessed the Truth About Esther ? ( C...

Who Guessed the Truth About Esther ? ( Contains Major Spoiler)


I did when I saw her Art which was far too mature in form and content to be that of a child.

reply

I didn't suspect a thing until the reveal. I kept expecting a supernatural element in the twist.

reply

Yes I did ... but I'd seen an episode of law & order svu about a week earlier with the same m subject. Still a good film though.

reply

Yeah, I guessed it...

[spoiler]...because someone had already told me.[/spoiler]

reply

I never saw this movie but read about it and the premise seems similar to a real-life case of Birdie Jo Hoaks. She was in her 20s and would pretend to be a young runaway boy to get shelter and food. Most people believed it and took her in as a boy. Then her story begin to unravel. She never killed anyone, just a lot of fraud.

reply

[deleted]

I guessed this early. I cannot remember exactly when as I saw it when it first came out, but I remember it being early in the movie and was surprised I was right cuz I am not usually.

reply