MovieChat Forums > Up (2009) Discussion > Loved the story right up until this bit

Loved the story right up until this bit


..when Carl symbolically accepts the past by ridding his house of its Ellie-related contents in order to make it airborne.

That was the main battle in the film, between his past and present. After that the battle with Muntz's gang was merely a physical one, with no symbolic stakes. I'm not against action, but when it becomes merely a sequence of stunts with no meaning, I immediately get bored.

Don't get me wrong, I loved the poignancy of Carl's backstory and the adventure's meaning. If somehow the acceptance of past had been timed with the physical battle, everything would have come together, similar to the Carl's previous choice of saving the burning house at the cost of Muntz capturing the netted Snape. In other words, they needed to delay resolving the emotional stakes until the end of the film.

reply

That's kind of the point of the movie. Him realizing he hadn't failed his wife and her "adventure dreams."
They had a nice life together; he just never thought he fulfilled her dreams until having the guts to flip past the "stuff I'm going to do page" in her adventure book and seeing how happy she was with him and their life together.

reply

Exactly. He's made amends with his lost wife. Now he's setting out to do what she always wanted for him.



"Seahawks-38, Patriots- 0"- AH_Fan


reply

Maybe it's a gradual realisation

reply