I don't see this. As far as Transformers story telling goes, the cartoon is garbage. Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan, but it was a dumb show with continuity errors and horrid dialogue. I think what Bay and the writers did to adapt it as a movie was great. I was crazy entertained. Were there stuff that sucked? Sure. Thought the designs were waaayyy too complicated. And would have loved more Optimus screen time, but showing any of those guys were pretty damn expensive, so I'm sure they had to work around the budget. But if I had to pick the movie or the cartoon, I'd pick the movie.
As Gi Joe goes, I think the adaption is far worse than the source. I felt that all the characters were super flat and dumb. When they were attacked by the MARS troops, why did the soldiers stay in the open and fire? Why was Duke able to defeat Snake Eyes in combat? Why the hell they gave Duke and Ripcord this incredibly advanced Iron Man suits when they were fairly new to the squad and relatively untrusted? The connection with Doctor, Baroness, and Duke was not necessary to me.
As far as respecting the source, I thought Transformers did a good job. The writers showed a lot of love to the franchise. Bay just did his thing with the action and I felt it worked. G.I Joe, I got none of that. I actually stopped paying attention around the training montage because I was just not liking it.
Watch these movies!!:
American History X, Zombieland, Kick Ass, anything Hayao Miyazaki
reply
share