MovieChat Forums > My Best Friend's Girl (2008) Discussion > 3 Versions of this movie! The clean one...

3 Versions of this movie! The clean one is GREAT!

posted 16 years ago by gillies
6 replies | jump to latest

There are 3 versions of this movie !!!

- Clean version, In the bar, Tank is an "animal", there are no sex toys, no visit to a porn house, kate is not in her underwear, etc. This version is GREAT! I saw it on an airplane and it could probably play on prime time TV! The love story really comes through, and the tank character is very likeable, actually !!!

- DVD version, In the bar, Tank is an a*hole this is a much raunchier version, I would say that the raunch only hurts the storyline, try to ignore it !!

- DVD version, unrated! This version is truly rude, they go into great graphic detail, I think the producers thought they were making a porno film or something, this version is awful !! Run away !!! Run Away !!

Anyway, I loved #1, but I'm lukewarm on #2, and I had to turn off #3 because it was so raunchy and disgusting I couldn't watch it any more (and I'm a guy!)

Ratings :

version 1 - 7.5 - 8.0 stars
version 2 - 6.5 stars
version 3 - 2 stars at most!!!

[–] Roiin07 16 years ago

Go back to My Best Friend's Wedding, you sissy. Too raunchy? I'm not even pro-raunch, but I'm not going to piss and moan about it. It was actually great. The best part of comedy is dirty jokes and misogynism--wake up.

[–] mitch-189 16 years ago

Oh yeah, misogynism is sooo hot these days.

Kook.

I just watched the unedited version and it was the worst movie I've seen in a loooong time. Not even close to being worth the five lousy bucks it cost me to see this on cable. It wasn't that it was offensive, it was just a lousy, nearly 100% un-funny movie.

[–] Jon364 15 years ago

A clean version of this movie would be totally boring, and pointless. There are better movies out there for a clean comedy romance, with better characters, and a better story. These type of movies are dirty for a reason. They have a brand of humour you can't find in other movies.

Many years ago American Pie came out and shocked everyone. My best friend saw it in the cinema with his mother. They were both in for a shock. These days things are alot more open and it's harder to get that shock effect. Movies like this are the new American Pie. If you are watching it with your family, there are better choices. If you are watching it with some college friends over some beers, it's a great movie.

[–] gillies 15 years ago

The unrated version would likely make Howard Stern fans puke. It was really a lousy movie. See all three versions (if you can stand it) before commenting on this movie. You may not have even seen the pointlessly raunchy and unfunny versions yet !!

[–] GlorielTheGlorious 14 years ago

You know it's funny, when I was younger every time an "unrated" dvd version of a film I'd seen at the theatre came out, I'd rent it and try to spot a difference. Slowly I've been realizing that what Americans fuss about and cut from films, is the material we *always* see at theatres in my country... and I don't think we have all that many Howard Stern fans. The committy that gives films their rating over here simply respects an adult audience to sit through a bit of nudity and crude comments.

'Sooner or later... you really wear that suit'

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]