MovieChat Forums > Suspiria (2018) Discussion > Who really likes remakes?

Who really likes remakes?


This is just stupid remaking a cult classic film. The original was as good as it will get, so what is the point of it being remade? It'll just confuse younger people into thinking this is THE Suspiria, and they will never end up hearing of the original.

Why are film makers so unoriginal these days?

reply

The problem with remakes isn't unoriginality. There are plenty of films that I think can be remade with new ideas added and new themes explored upon. The problem with remakes is that most remakes are Hollywood productions, and they're just cynical commercial products banking on brand name recognition, so Hollywood producers don't want anything new added to the film. Now if you look at the producers of the Suspiria remake, 9 out of 12 of the producers are Italians, and none of the producers seem like Hollywood high rollers. Some seem very indie, and one has his name attached to many ambitious films, including Let Me In, which I'll admit I haven't seen, but I hear is actually a really good remake of Let the Right One In. Besides, they have an Italian art house filmmaker directing it. I'd rather an Italian art house guy be doing it than an American horror director who'll just add more horror cliches to the movie.

Also, if younger people are going to think the remake is THE Supiria without ever hearing about the original, then they would never have ended up hearing about the original Suspiria even in the first place cause the only young people who would no about the original are into older movies.

100 Greatest Action Movies - http://www.imdb.com/list/ls000708268/

reply

Look at the Maniac remake from a few years back. That's one of the best horror remakes ever, and that's because it understood what worked about the original and updated it for modern context. That was a French/American production. The Suspiria remake is going to be an Italian/American production.

100 Greatest Action Movies - http://www.imdb.com/list/ls000708268/

reply

Actually people usually want to watch the original after a remake, have you never heard about hipsters? I am ok with this remake, a bit thrilled I must say, but it is very easy to screw this one up, they need to give a lot of freedom to the director and DoP and editor and colorist ^^

reply

I still think it's a stupid idea, because it's almost 100% guaranteed to suck. Like all remakes. The camera work will be all wrong, there will be no atmosphere, and the cast will probably be annoying.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]