MovieChat Forums > Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps (2010) Discussion > Does Shia LeBeouf ruin every movie he's ...

Does Shia LeBeouf ruin every movie he's in?


Or more accurately is Shia LeBeauf always in a bad movie? Constantine-Bad. Eagle Eye-Bad. Indiana Jones 4-GOD AWFUL. Disturbia-Ugh. Wall Street 2-The WORST!

I will let him off the hook with Transformers, not that I think the movie is good but Michael Bay has a unique formula of making movies sappy and successful.

Anyway you look at it, Shia LeBeauf is one of those supposed "Up and Coming" actors that is just a DUD. I put him in the Paul Walker category, you just don't want to see him in a movie, either he ruins it or it's just plain BAD.

reply

Transformers sucked too.

reply

His movies have a reputation of making money, so expect to see a lot more of him in the future.

reply

> is Shia LeBeauf always in a bad movie?

Hmm. I guess so. To tell you the truth, I'm scarcely even familar with him, because "Wall Street 2" is the only one of the movies you list that I've seen. Must be because the other ones are ... well, bad.

I didn't think he was particularly bad in this movie, though. Anyway, he didn't ruin it. That already happened before he showed up, thanks to a hackneyed misconception and unimaginative, unfocused screenplay.

Then again, he wasn't particularly good either. He wasn't unbelievable as the character or anything, but he was just sort of blandly there. I suppose that's what the part called for, being a cardboardy character. I wonder, though, what a more lively actor - or just one with a bit more personality - might have brought to the part. The younger John Cusack played some characters who were fairly blank (even one named that), but you could scarcely say they lacked personality or interest once he was done with them.

I am, however, one of the several dozen people who actually saw LeBeouf in "Battle of Shaker Heights" (in a theater, no less!). He was pretty decent, actually ... which may be the result of some combination of: (i) low expectations, (ii) Oliver Stone having mellowed into an even worse director of actors than a pair of never-weres or (iii) better material, if you can believe that.

reply

Wall Street 2 was not the worst. Go see him in "A Guide To Recognizing Your Saints." It's the movie that landed him Spielberg's support.

I worked hard for this I need nobody

reply

Just about. I didn't hate Disturbia, but he didn't shine in any of the others.

Indy 4 was his worst.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I don't think he was bad in this but I don't think he had much to work with. He is a good actor, and I can see him on the Street. They are not all Josh Brolin types.

reply

It's not the movies he picks, it's just him. He has been given good-to-great material (A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints and The Greatest Game Ever Played, for example) and just does nothing with it. Since he is young in most cases I would just say 'oh he'll get better as he ages' but the thing is, Shia has been acting for 13 years. If he hasn't been able to turn in a good performance after all these years I just can't ever see it happening.

"We stopped checking for monsters under our bed when we realized they were inside us"

reply