MovieChat Forums > Hawkeye (2021) Discussion > So Hawkeye doesn't get to be the hero of...

So Hawkeye doesn't get to be the hero of his own show. (series finale spoilers)


Kingpin is defeated by the young female sidekick, while Hawkeye gets his butt kicked by Black Widow's sister. What kind of bait-and-switch nonsense is this? Can we get a Hawkeye show where Hawkeye gets to be the hero and actually defeat the villain? Is that too much to ask in 2021?

Don't get me wrong, the buddy comedy stuff was great, both between Hailey and Jeremy and between Hailey and Florence, but the show is called HAWKEYE.

reply

Kate Bishop is also called Hawkeye in the comic books.

reply

I'm sure everyone expected Clint Barton to be the star of the show. In the MCU, he is the one and only Hawkeye. Even in the comic books, Kate Bishop is a relatively new character. Mention Hawkeye to the average comic book fan, and they'll think of Clint, not Kate. Also, the show is called Hawkeye, not Hawkeyes.

reply

Hawkeye was every bit the star of the show. The other characters had their moments, but he was the central figure. The story revolved around him accepting Kate as his partner, and presumably his eventual replacement, as he's on the verge of retirement. I thought it was well-handled, and everyone had a chance to shine.

reply

You forgot putting rest his past burning the old Ronin fatigues therefore concluding the Ronin saga for good.

reply

Exactly, and this follows similar to Factions run, and she was a badass in that too .

reply

Because Hawkeye's main villain in this show was Yelena. Kate had a more personal connection to Kingpin since he was forcing her mom to be in his organization. Beyond that, Clint kicked Kazi's ass in nearly every episode, beat up Echo in the previous episode, and was generally more badass in this show than he ever was in the movies.

reply

Yelena didn't even show up until the series was half over. You're basically defending the show by saying it was written to be that way, while I'm saying that writing it that way is a bait-and-switch.

I'd love a Yelena and Kate Bishop show, but this was supposed to be the Clint Barton show.

reply

If it was supposed to be the Clint Barton show, it would've been written that way. You set your own expectations.

reply

It was called Hawkeye. The expectations are obvious for the vast majority of the audience.

reply

Kate Bishop is also Hawkeye though as someone already said. Just because she's not who people would think of first when you mention Hawkeye, doesn't mean she isn't also Hawkeye. She's also not very new having debuted as a character in 2005 and having the Hawkeye name pretty much since the beginning.

Like the Black Widow movie, the show serves as a means to send off one iteration of the character while setting up another.

Maybe that was the expectation for casual audiences, but not actual Marvel fans.

reply

Curious how you're defining "actual Marvel fans." I've been buying Marvel comic books since 1984 and own literally thousands of them. How about you?

reply

I define an actual Marvel fan as someone who's a fan of Marvel as a whole, not just one aspect of it. There's a difference between being a fan of Marvel movies and being a fan of Marvel.

reply

I think you're heading into "no true Scotsman" territory. This "actual Marvel fan" expected the Hawkeye show to have Clint Barton be the hero.

reply

Who cares how many comic books you've purchased, or when you started. I've been reading and collecting comics since 1978. Am I somehow an even greater authority, or more respectable audience member, than you?

I think the show was very well done. Hawkeye was the clear star, he was in control and we saw him take charge in ways we never got to see in his ensemble films. We also met some up and coming new stars who will be propelling the franchise forward in years to come. Best, we were given believable reasons for this transition. Barton is older, deaf from explosions, misses his family, and is generally old and tired and ready to move on in life. He came out to put the Ronin chapter of his life behind him, and now he's passed the torch to a new Hawkeye.

reply

It's a shame that Hawkeye's ONLY solo outing in the MCU is all about passing the torch to someone else. They should have given him an adventure all his own first.

And I mentioned when I started buying Marvel comic books and how many I own because the person I was replying to suggested that I had different expectations of the show because I'm part of the "casual audience" instead of an "actual Marvel fan." You would know if that if you had read the thread and comprehended it.

reply

"Like the Black Widow movie, the show serves as a means to send off one iteration of the character while setting up another."

So Hawkeye never gets his own movie and the only TV show he gets is just to set up the next Hawkeye. Thanks a lot, Disney. Actually, it's worse than that. This wasn't just setting up the next Hawkeye. This was the Kate Bishop show from the very beginning.

reply

“You're basically defending the show by saying it was written to be that way”

It was indeed written to be that way. Especially since Yelena was set up to be a villain for Clint before the series ever started filming.

And beyond that, Kingpin didn’t show up in full until the very last episode.

reply

So you're agreeing with me that they made some nutty writing decisions.

reply

Not really. Having villains showing up later in a story is nothing new.

reply

I'm referring more to the idea that Yelena was "set up" to be a villain for Clint. I didn't see much set-up. She just showed up halfway through and attacked Clint immediately. No set up at all.

reply

You didn't see much set up? You didn't see the end credits scene for Black Widow where we see her getting hired to kill him? That was a plot point before a single episode dropped.

reply

I haven't seen the Black Widow film yet.

reply

You seem to be a big MCU fan so I’m surprised you didn’t watch it.

reply

I heard about what they did to Taskmaster and was so disappointed that I haven't made the time to watch it, yet. I'll get around to it. I have to watch Shang-Chi, as well. Never particularly cared for that character.

reply

Clint's depiction I think is one of the strongest points of this show. I was wondering if he was gonna be downgraded from his ability in the movies but I think the way it's shown, he clearly outclasses virtually everyone he deals with. He's pulling his punches for the most part.

reply

Kingpin got shot with two arrows and hit by a car and still kicked the shit out of her. She "won" by blowing up a bomb in his face. Not exactly an ass-kicking moment for her.

reply

She won. She did better against Kingpin than Clint Barton did against Black Widow's sister.

reply

She threw a bomb at him after getting owned for 10 minutes.

reply

Getting owned? Daredevil got owned when he faced Kingpin for the first time. Kate Bishop defeated Kingpin and walked away practically unscathed.

reply

Did you miss the part where she was thrown around the room multiple times and utterly ignored by Kingpin? She was on the ground bloody and only won by luck.

reply

Mere minutes later she's watching her Mom get arrested and palling around with Clint. Doesn't even have a limp. I don't see anyone calling an ambulance for her.

reply

And Clint was getting beaten in the face with an iron rod without any injuries or death. And Fisk was hit by a car and had a bomb go off under him and he still walked away. Is this the first time you’ve seen a superhero story?

reply

Watch some Daredevil on Netflix. Then tell me how badly Kate Bishop was beaten.

reply

I’ve seen all three seasons of Daredevil. It’s my favorite comicbook show. Not that that has anything to do with the points I made but it seems you are ignoring them completely so that’s cool I guess.

reply

Well, who seemed to have an easier time fighting Kingpin? Daredevil or Kate Bishop? I'll give you that Kingpin was holding back a lot fighting Bishop, because he could see that she's a young woman.

reply

Daredevil had the easier time fighting Kingpin. No question. How is this a contest?

reply

Daredevil lost when he fought Kingpin for the first time. It wasn't even close.

reply

You mean after Nobu sliced Matt up and he could hardly even stand? Not a fair fight. How about going by their first REAL fight? You know, the one where Daredevil beat up Kingpin?

reply

Daredevil is supposed to beat people at hand to hand combat. Kate is first and foremost an archer.

reply

You are right. Not a fair fight. Have you read the Born Again comic book? I highly recommend it.

reply

I have. Very good story.

reply

God, I hope you are trolling, because if you are not, that would mean you are INCREDIBLY stupid.

reply

You're making it sound like she was carted away on a stretcher after facing Kingpin. Watch it again. She's on her own two feet and completely coherent. She's fine.

reply

Barton didn't try to beat up Yelena. He let her work through her rage, then reasoned with her. That was one of the underlying themes of the show that perhaps you missed. Just like Clint became Ronin and murdered people when he mourned his family, Yelena needed to work through what she was feeling after losing Natasha. If he'd pummeled her into submission, nothing would change. He had to let her get there on her own.

reply

His comment about Kate and Kingpin is moronic because he clearly kicked the shit out of her, but I do think it came off like Clint couldn't beat her. He was trying to subdue her at first when it got to the point she was trying to kill her, if he could stop her, why didn't he? Because he couldn't. He didn't do well against her or Echo.

Marvel has pulled this heroes can't beat the villain a little too much lately.

reply

I felt like he could have killed Echo, but he was pulling his punches with her.

With Yelena, I'm still on the fence about their power scaling. I'm not entirely sure who would actually win if they went all out against each other. I do agree with the other guy though that I don't think Clint was trying that hard. His inability to subdue might just mean that he doesn't outclass her enough to be able to subdue her alone, if that makes sense.

This is gonna sound like a cheesy, absurdly personal analogy but if I'm playing a game with someone, and I'm better than them...

I can't pull my punches unless I'm significantly better than them. Because if I'm much better, I have an understanding of how I can manipulate my own advantage while acknowledging theirs.

If I'm only a little bit stronger than them, I can probably still beat them every time, but if I tried to slow down the pace of the game, I'd just end up losing.

So in my mind, Clint doesn't outclass Yelena to the point where he can punk her (which is what I think he did with Maya). But for Yelena, if he fought enough to protect himself, he'd probably beat and injure Yelena, and he doesn't want that.

One could also argue that he does partially blame himself and doesn't mind being the whipping boy there, but I won't take it that far.

Marvel has pulled this heroes can't beat the villain a little too much lately.


...I'm trying to be optimistic lol

reply

I don't remember Clint outclassing Maya. I remember her being the aggressor and then him subduing her when he broke out his sword. I admit I have only watched each episode once, and some of these are several weeks old, and I could be wrong, but I don't remember Clint winning a single fight against someone who wasn't a henchmen.

He was trying to fend off Yelena at first, but I don't buy the "he wasn't trying to hurt him" when it gets to the point of him trying to kill her. What was he going to do, let her kill him because he didn't want to hurt her? It just came off like he couldn't beat her at a certain point.

I liked this show quite a bit - I found it to be extremely entertaining - but there were several things about it that bothered me.

reply

Clint beat both Kate and Maya. He didn't lose any fight. In the final showdown with Yelena he knew she was Natasha's sister, he wasn't going to try to win that fight.

In fact He beat Maya when she had dozens of henchmen to protect her. He took out all of the Henchmen and beat Maya quite quickly. He could have killed her if he wanted to.

reply

I'll have to rewatch the Maya fight. I just saw that like a day or two before I wrote this, but I'm pretty he was advantaged; I did feel pretty confident about that.

I was gonna rewatch the Yelena fight anyways cause I said, I'm honestly still trying to decide how I feel about it. To be perfectly honest, part of me is also oscillating on the possibility that he doesn't really care about dying either. Yes, he wants to get back to his family. Yes, he had the whistle as his trump card. From his very first appearance in this show, Clint feels like a character who's only a few feet from the ledge.

reply

Hey — many disagree with you (based on many reactions I’ve seen all over, of course). In fact many who previously feared that he was going to be sidelined in his own series (and yes, Kate is supposed to become HAWKEYE herself), changed their tune.

This whole show was inspired by one specific comic arc, and I say the show did not only do the source material justice but the MCU’s Clint Barton justice. Nay? Well, okay.

Complain as many do.

reply

Uh...did you miss the fact that this show isn't all about Clint from just the first episode alone?

reply

Not only did I not miss it, I posted this thread to complain about it. I'd rather the Hawkeye show be all about Clint. Because it's the Hawkeye show.

reply

She is also Hawkeye

reply

Just give the guy his own standalone adventure before making him pass the torch to someone else.

reply

No need.

reply

Shockingly, I remain unpersuaded by your anemic rhetoric.

reply

I would agree but to be honest the synopsis says : "Series based on the Marvel Comics superhero Hawkeye , centering on the adventures of Young Avenger, Kate Bishop, who took on the role after the original Avenger, Clint Barton."



reply