um quick question


If he was going to be damned and start fighting again, he may have done it b4 they killed the boy!!!

reply

um he didn't know they would kill him. Um he also didn't know how much anger he would feel after they did it.

reply

"Is this all I am to you...?"

Great scene. Packed a punch for me, personally.

SHERLOCK HOLMES (2009) WAS A HORRIBLE MOVIE. ACCEPT IT.

reply

If he was going to be damned and start fighting again, he may have done it b4 they killed the boy!!!


Would've been nice, but I guess he needed a push to take up the sword again.

reply

Not many films would have killed the boy, they would have killed the family and kidnapped brother and daughter...

When they followed through with it I was actually surprised

reply

Same here. I was glad they killed the kid. Yes, I just said that. It's a character, not a human being, and as a plot-device, killing the boy was a good idea.

"Sometimes I'm callous and strange."

reply

Agree but I try the Solomon Kane drinking game anyway.

Every time someone yells or screams take a shot. When an oath is sworn take two. I guarantee that you'll be on-the-floor hammered before 10 minutes is up.

reply

Yep. That's when I stopped caring. Manipulative melodramatic revenge crap.

For every lie I unlearn I learn something new - Ani Difranco

reply