Can someone explain what actually happened to Doug's parents?
I wasnt super following "The Florist" in his weird/eerie/creepy explanation scene. "Chemicals"?
shareI wasnt super following "The Florist" in his weird/eerie/creepy explanation scene. "Chemicals"?
shareFor starters: Doug's mother left Doug and his father when Doug was around six years old, due to Mac Sr's criminal lifestyle. Fergie the Florist, who Doug and his accomplices in crime ultimately ended up working for (as Doug's father had done before him.), imho, sterilized Doug's father in both the literal way and the figurative way: Fergie injected Mac Sr. (i. e. Doug's father) with female hormones that shut down the production of testosterone, and also got Doug's mother hooked on heroin. Doug's mother ultimately commited suicide by hanging herself. So, Fergie the Florist sterilized Doug's father in both the literal and figurative way, imo.
shareFergie injected Mac Sr. (i. e. Doug's father) with female hormones that shut down the production of testosterone
I have to disagree with you too, mburton81.
Fergie may not have taken out Doug's father, but, given the way Doug's father looked when Doug visited him in prison (much fatter, pot-bellied, more round-shouldlered and shrunken), I stand by what I've said about Fergie having sterilized Doug's father in the literal, as well as the figurative way. Nobody's disputing that Fergie got Doug's mom hooked on heroin, resulting in her death, but I firmly believe that Fergie did sterilize "Mac" Senior (i. e. Doug's father) with female hormones, as well.
[deleted]
You can disagree with him all you want. You're idea is insanely preposterous and out in left field, and is also based on absolutely no evidence whatsoever.
shareBy hurling insults at me, YOU'RE proving that YOU'RE insane and out in left field, J0hnayres.
shareNo, I'm not. Nice try though.
shareNo, I'm not. Nice try though.
He didn't hurl any insults at you. He said your ideas were preposterous and out in left field. He used the word insanely to modify the word preposterous. If you find someone else's opinion of your opinion an insult then that's your problem.
All that being said, there is no evidence in the movie that supports your opinion. When the florist spoke about controlling Doug's father chemically he was saying he got Doug's mom hooked on drugs, leading her to kill herself thus showing the father who was in control.
So what? I stand by what I've said here, and I really don't give a rat's ass what you or anybody else things, sying. Doug was a stupid guy anyway, for blowing his chance to form a decent life for himself and become a decent person and to really get out of the criminal lifestyle. So was Doug's father, for letting himself fall under Fergie's spell in the first place.
shareFirst, why the hostility? I wasn't being hostile towards you. I simply pointed out the previous poster didn't insult you? You seem touchy. What's up with that?
Second, I can certainly respect the fact you stick to your idea. I, and others, simply don't think it's supported by anything in the movie. You say Stephen was pot bellied and such and that's proof that he was injected with estrogen? I don't know if you've noticed but Chris Cooper isn't exactly the most in shape of guys. That's not exactly irrefutable proof.
Finally, what would the motivation be? The point of Fergie figuratively castrating Stephen was to motivate him into doing the work? How would injecting female hormones do that? That would seem like it would get the opposite reaction.
Oh, and before you reply with what I imagine would be hostility again, remember that those that reply in such a way are on the defensive and their arguments are shaky. I believe you even pointed that out once.
[deleted]
This:
riendoffilm has got to be one of the dumbest persons on imdb boards.
That or you have some kind of a mental disorder that affects your reasoning ability.
It is not that you're not allowed to have your opinion... BUT within the context of the film, that teory simply doesn't fly. This is a gritty crime-drama. Besides, I think you would need more than one injection to simply stop the production of testosterone. If you can provide actual evidence that ONE injection can do this, I will cheerfully back you up.
Furthermore, old men get a kind of saggy as they get old. And given that MacRay Sr. is to do nothing but spend the rest of his life in a jail-cell, he would have become fatter and his body would begin to ache more from the lack of proper excercise.
"sterilized Doug's father in both the literal way and the figurative way: Fergie injected Mac Sr. (i. e. Doug's father) with female hormones that shut down the production of testosterone"
Wait, what...?
If you love Jesus Lizard and are 100% proud of it, copy this and make it your signature!
Fergie's story wasn't to be taken literally, in the way that you would chemically geld an animal. Fergie says "When your daddy said no to me, I did him the chemical way - gave your mother a taste". When Doug's father didn't want to work for Fergie, he got Doug's mother hooked on drugs, resulting in her death.
shareergie's story wasn't to be taken literally, in the way that you would chemically geld an animal.
Fergie says "When your daddy said no to me, I did him the chemical way - gave your mother a taste". When Doug's father didn't want to work for Fergie, he got Doug's mother hooked on drugs, resulting in her death.
This is Fergie's explanation in the screenplay:
They either geld a horse with a
knife or with the chemicals.
(beat)
When your father said no to me I
did him the chemical way -- I gave
your mother a taste. Put the hook
in her. Then I turned her out.
She doped up and hung herself with
a wire down on Melnea Cass.
I have to disagree with you, Robot-Werewolf, and I stand by what I've said. I see the way it's written, and I still stand by my position that Fergie more than likely sterilized Doug's father in the literal, as well as the figurative way. That, imho, is why the script at that point was a real gross-out for me.
I'm not talking about physical behavior on the part of Doug MacRay's permanently-incarcerated father, either, Robot-Werewolf. I'm saying that Doug MacRay's father looks more like a much older, post-menopausal woman. There's an important difference between behaving like someone and looking like them. Just because the screenplay doesn't offer any such detail about a certain way in which he carries himself, or anything unusual about "Mac" Sr.'s behavior, doesn't meant that it can't be observed if one looks hard enough and long enough at his way of carrying himself and acting.
Imho, that holds true of any movie. Subtleties can be and often are noticed, if one looks closely enough, imho. The way Fergie pronounced the word "horses" sounded terse enough and major enough so that he also meant it literally, as well as physically, as well.
Oh, I see. Well, you make more effort than most of the others do on here nowadays.
share[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
I agree with you, R-W. Frankly it baffles me that anyone could interpret that dialog to mean that Doug's father was literally gelded but whatever.
How do the angels get to sleep when the Devil leaves his porchlight on.
I firmly and honestly believe you are really reaching. You honestly think chemical castration is a single shot of female hormones? You think Doug's dad just showed up for his weekly injection? I honestly and firmly can't believe someone could misinterpret what the florist was saying. I don't know how much more clear they could make it.
shareI still disagree with your opinion and everybody else's opinions that I'm overreaching. What makes you think that just a shot of female hormones won't shut off the production of testosterone, or that Fergie didn't give Doug MacRay's father more than one shot of female hormones at a time?
I stand by what I've said so far.
Just before the "gelding" speech, Fergie says "You're going to do this for me, or I'm going to clip your nuts like I clipped your daddy's."
But he didn't actually clip Stephen MacRay's nuts or actually chemically castrate him; he was speaking metaphorically. He got Doug's mom addicted to heroin and she eventually killed herself. In the same scene, Fergie threatens Claire, which is why Doug comes back and shoots Fergie.
Fergie said "I did him the chemical way. Gave your mother a taste." not "I did him the chemical way and also gave your mother a taste." Getting Doug's mom addicted was how he "did him the chemical way".
I read into it a bit differently, muveewachr. Regardless of what anybody else on here says or thinks, I still believe that Fergie sterilized Stephen MacRay in both the literal (the injection of a female hormone(s) to shut off the flow of testosterone.) and the figurative way (getting Doug's mom hooked on scag (heroin), and she ultimately committed suicide).
share[deleted]
Noons1647: You're the stupid one!
Lol twice as hard back at you!
How so?
I'm not the one who is so vehemently pushing an asinine, ludicrous, and totally ridiculous theory. At first I thought you were joking, but as I kept reading it became obvious: You're just dumb (and immature).
You're just dumb (and immature).
No, again you aren't mature enough to handle someone pointing out to you that you might be wrong. You're theory is so far-fetched and ludicrous that I actually feel embarrassed for you.
But you can go ahead and say, "Nu-uh YOU are!" It doesn't change anything. (And me being an A-hole also doesn't change anything. I am an A-hole, but that's really just beside the point).
You're way beyond being an A-hole, noone1647! You're obviously not mature enough to not resort to insults, either. You are a piece of s**t who thinks s/he's a big shot, but you're really a nobody mixed with nothing underneath it. Crawl back under that rock, *beep*
You know something else, noone1647? You totally suck as a person, so I have zero respect for you!
Well an anonymous person on the internet not respecting me really doesn't affect me in any way, shape, or form.
However, watching you go totally bat$hit crazy after pointing out to you that his father being chemically sterilized is so utterly absurd that you must be a mental defective for even considering such nonsense is very entertaining.
I think that you're the one who's batsh$#t crazy here, buddy! Your insults to me and anybody else who doesn't agree with what you're saying don't prove that I'm abnormal, but you're merely proving your own abnormalities and short-comings, because you don't seem to know how to disagree in a civil manner.
I'll also add, noone1647, that by calling me a "mental defective", you're not proving that I'm defective, but that you're the mental defective here. Put that in your pipe and smoke it, buster!
Hey buddy....suck!
1) Explain what I've done that was "bat$hit crazy". 2) You are the only one I've insulted. There are no others.
Your last sentence actually makes LESS sense than your castration theory.
Explain what I've done that was "bat$hit crazy".
?
How does merely insulting someone cause them to be "bat$hit crazy"?
Do you know what "crazy" means?
How does merely insulting someone cause them to be "bat$hit crazy"?
Do you know what "crazy" means?
Getting alot of mileage out of that "I know you are but what am I" defense, huh.
shareNot only did you literally think he was castrated but you continue to defend your laughable theory. You are either :
1. A troll.
2. *beep* insane.
3. A retard.
lol. Still running the ole "I know you are but what am I?" defense.
shareWhy does every comments thread on the internet wind up with douchebags arguing over stupid *beep*
shareby friendoffilm » Mon May 12 2014 06:26:21
I still disagree with your opinion and everybody else's opinions that I'm overreaching. What makes you think that just a shot of female hormones won't shut off the production of testosterone, or that Fergie didn't give Doug MacRay's father more than one shot of female hormones at a time?
I stand by what I've said so far.
Here's another thing, wizaz02: What makes you think that Fergie didn't sterilize Doug MacRay's father in both the literal and figurative way, by actually neutering him physically by cutting "Mac" MacRay Sr.'s testicles off and then giving him an injection of a female hormone to shut off the flow of hormones? I think that, too, is possible.
shareHere's another thing, wizaz02: What makes you think that Fergie didn't sterilize Doug MacRay's father in both the literal and figurative way, by actually neutering him physically by cutting "Mac" MacRay Sr.'s testicles off and then giving him an injection of a female hormone to shut off the flow of hormones? I think that, too, is possible.
shareNot sure why no one's mentioning this part of what the florist said
Then I turned her out.
I stand by everything I've said here.
share[deleted]
Yeah well you shut the f-ck up by everything you've said
There's something seriously wrong with all of you.
Doug's Dad - Worked for the Florist...did an armored car job in Nashua that went badly and ended in the death of both guards...doing life in prison for it.
Doug's Mom - Got intentionally hooked on heroin by the Florist, died.
^
What Bass said. (including the first bit.)
The florist told Doug, quite clearly, that the father wanted to leave him and do his own thing, which the florist would not allow, so to punish him, he got Doug's mother hooked on heroin, then she committed suicide. That's how he "chemically" castrated the father. The father told Doug that she had left them, to spare him knowing that she killed herself.
- And this is critical to understanding the entire plot, esp early on when Doug discusses with the other member of his team how he wants to quit, and the other guy says that you can't just walk away.
What makes anybody think that Doug's father wouldn't started robbing banks, armored trucks, etc., on his own if he had succeeded in leaving Fergie?
shareThanks for starting the thread. It confused me too.
share[deleted]
I'm with you on this one, TheNativeButcher. I'm inclined to think that Fergie castrated Doug's father in both the literal (actual physical castration.), and figuratively (i. e. getting Doug's father's wife hooked on heroin, which happens more slowly.)
share