MovieChat Forums > The Pink Panther 2 (2009) Discussion > That Indian chick(?) needs acting lesson...

That Indian chick(?) needs acting lessons.


Pronto.
Why didn't they cast someone who could act?

reply

And we thought Beyonce was bad.

reply

[deleted]

she was taking acting lesson since 10 years

well i guess she is hopeless in acting department


dont worry we will export another Indian chick who can act

reply

[deleted]

Huge female following. But Rai's Holywood films have been flops. Acting lessons might help.



(there are zero indian actresses that are glamourous that have made a name for themselves here in the US. )

Are you kidding? Try Freida Pinto.

(dont worry we will export another Indian chick who can act)
Hopefully FP can fit the bill.



reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Right on! (And I'm Indian by the way)

reply

Thanks. Looked up Freida Pinto. Yeehaw hottie. That one is getting a lot of exposure now. Awards and all.

reply

ur 100% right....

reply

[deleted]

well its no suprise aishwarya fans think, she is the most beautiful Indian

just go and visit any village in India,you will see more beautiful women than aish,aish is make up made



reply

Never heard of her before this movie
She looks like a drag queen dude. Her acting is hilarious.
Her fans seem like some brainwashed female cult.

reply

[deleted]

What IS Zhang Ziyi to China? BTW, she legally changed her name around for "more western appeal". Ziyi Zhang.

Wanting to know since I am a Gong Li fan. Since Li is the most important, best actress (and beautiful IMO) to come out of China. You are not gonna find a lot of Ziyi fans in China.
As far as I know Rai, as well as Gong Li and Ziyi Zhang have not been that successful in Hollywood.

Glad to Freida Pinto is breaking in representing India.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I felt that she did a good job in this film but I would have rather have seen them get someone who is more well known than Aishwarya Rai was to be honest with you. I know who she is because I have heard about her but she really has not done any film to make her stand out like other actresses have.

Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show! www.deefilmroll.com/usa-uan/

reply

The role could have been played by any actress. It was no stretch.

reply

Yes the role could have been played by any actress but they did not get any other actress but the Indian actress.

Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show! www.deefilmroll.com/usa-uan/

reply

u AIsh basher
just coz u like Li Gong dont come and Bash Aish
go home and do stir fry

AIsh was sexy in the film and she did what role demanded her to do.
and it was all fine.

AISHWARYA RAI IS AWSOME>

reply

I am an Indian, and Aishwarya trying to showcase Indian talent in HW is a shame.

We have Irrfan Khan, Freida Pinto, Tabu, even Anil Kapoor now to showcase Indian talent.

I would send Shabana Aazmi, Madhuri Dixit(for dance), Sridevi, Juhi Chawla, Tabu, Kajol, Rani Mukerji, Naseer-ud-din Shah, Irrfan Khan, Konkana Sen Sharma, Ranvir Shourey to HW than the green eyed bimbette to familiarise HW people with Indian talent.

Freida, Anil have been noticed after just one film!!!! And how!! They are bigger stars in HW now than Aishwarya who tried her luck in HW agaian and again by saying that she is the biggest Indian star.

And they are good actors. Anil has been doing wrong films in India, but whenever he did one right film(Chameli ki shaadi, Eeshwar, Lamhe), he was phenomenal.

Now dont try so hard to prove that she is here to stay and all, as even Indians know that she is not a good actress. She worked due to SLB films, but has been disastrous ever since. Dont give examples of Sarkar raj, Provoked(it was a critical failure as well as it earned her acting wishier, washier, wimpier adjectives), Raincoat(only deglamorise does not mean a great film), and blah blah to support ur cause.

Imagine, if these roles would have been played by other talented actresses, tehy would have become masterpieces.

Aishwarya in HW is what Meera(the Pakistani chick) was in India. They had better actors in Pakistan, and we have much better actors and dancers in India.

reply

[deleted]

No, she got few HW films due to aggressive campaign by her PR after the Cannes festival which showed Devdas. She was Miss World for 8 years before SLB took Devdas to Cannes, when she had arranged a good team of PR. Why did she not get noticed for those 8 years even after giving hits like HDDCS and Taal?

Irrfan Khan has done better roles than her in his HW films, and got respect as an actor too.

reply

Even Meera got few films with Mahesh Bhatt banner in India, that does not make her the best actress in Pakistan. The better actresses of pakistan never tried for Indian films. We know it was her PR working in India.

Do not act too innocent to understand simple things, just to show Aish in a better light.

reply

Funny u ask that-I am convinced that is one of the main reasons she is as famous in India as she is-the eyes. God knows what the big deal is but the Indian population digs it for some odd reason and has made a goddess out of her.

Personally-I think she is the most overrated actress Bollywood has ever seen. She cannot act for her life and her looks aren't anywhere close to deserving the supposed 'most beautiful woman in the world' title that she is given time and time again. Then again that title in itself is lame-unless one has managed to have seen every woman on this planet it really doesn't make sense to make such declarations.

Aish is extremely arrogant and she doesn't have much to offer to back up the arrogance. I've noticed time and time again she's an altogether different person when speaking to the Indian media versus the foreign media. Though in both cases she does manage to stay consistent with her fake accent, superficial expressions and extremely annoying voice.

reply

[deleted]

And Hollywoodfan,

Freida Pinto is the most famous Indian actress in HW today.

Even Tabbu(who herself keeps a low profile and does not do much films even in India). Atleast, critics in HW gave her respect as an actress.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Funny u ask that-I am convinced that is one of the main reasons she is as famous in India as she is-the eyes. God knows what the big deal is but the Indian population digs it for some odd reason and has made a goddess out of her.

Personally-I think she is the most overrated actress Bollywood has ever seen. She cannot act for her life and her looks aren't anywhere close to deserving the supposed 'most beautiful woman in the world' title that she is given time and time again. Then again that title in itself is lame-unless one has managed to have seen every woman on this planet it really doesn't make sense to make such declarations.

Aish is extremely arrogant and she doesn't have much to offer to back up the arrogance. I've noticed time and time again she's an altogether different person when speaking to the Indian media versus the foreign media. Though in both cases she does manage to stay consistent with her fake accent, superficial expressions and extremely annoying voice.



Agreed 100%... Aishwarya cannot act to save her life. Watching this movie was painful enough but to see her supposed acting?? HORRIBLE !!!
I would say this though, she does an okay job in Bollywood movies but when it comes to Hollywood... she seems VERY fake and rather uncomfortable in delivering lines in English. It's like she becomes very self conscious and screws it all up!

reply

lolz..she probably knows some head producer!

reply

(Tiny Spoiler)
Having recently seen this movie I had to say something about one of the worst performances in an otherwise well acted movie with subtle performances.
Aishwarya's just a plot element in a movie where every character is somewhat goofy in their own way. She tried to play her character straight(meaning reciting her lines) which is best considering her abilities and even then she failed. Atleast actresses playing bimbos in hollywood or bollywood movies do add some wickedness to their characters. The highlight of her performance is the way she says "ME!" when shes accused as being the thief as if someone asked her whether she farted or something.

reply

(She tried to play her character straight(meaning reciting her lines) which is best considering her abilities and even then she failed.)


Sad, but true. She really needs to invest in some acting leasons with a good teacher. Seriously.

reply

She would get the razzie or a nomination for worst supporting actress of 2009.

reply

Fingers crossed
The film should get some razzies too.

reply

I thought she was OK, I mean her nationality was never (purposely) explained. Anyway it is not like this movie was Hamlet or anything. It's just freaking Pink Panther 2.

Besides (SPOILER) when she fired her gun she did not even blink and usually this is the number one mistake actors make. I give her some points for that.

If you want to know if she can act or not, check out "Provoked".

reply

ppl in India dont know who Freida pinto is

Last movie seen:
STRIKER: 7/10
Love Aaj Kal: 8.5/10

reply

I'm an Indian; and I'll say leave conventional actors in their turf. Chinese, American, French, Indian, blah..blah.. Every actor (conventional; theater artists are more versatile, I think) follows a particular style from expressions to dialogue delivery. So whatever 'acting lessons' we provide to a foreign actor/actress; it will be worthless..

Everyone talking about that 'Pinto' chick is forgetting that she has almost zero acting experience in Bollywood even; so she is less 'over-expressive' (that is an essential part in our movie industry :D) Mrs. Rai has been acting (quite poorly if you ask me) for the last 10 years or so; and now; nothing can be done to 'change' her traits as an actress; for foreign adaptation. Even in 90% of her roles in BW; she performed as if she is putting way too much effort into it and almost every effort seemed quite..(??).. 'artificial' [a flick called 'Rain Coat' was an exception; she did good in that one..]

And while talking about Mr. Anil Kapoor; he too is sort of 'over-acting'; and that is nothing but the baggage carried over after being a lead star in BW.

One name that comes to my mind as someone who can be quite effective in HW too is Mr. Naseeruddin Shah. His role in that 'extraordinary FREAKS' didn't do much justice to his talent.

Better to Reign in Hell than to Serve in Heaven

reply

well it could of been a lot worse, sofia vergara could been cast instead?

reply