Up until the end, I thought she was going to be selfish and have herself killed cause I see Uma Thurman as an adult with her little girl Emma. Then it shows herself getting shot by that lunatic kid. So she sacraficed herself for her friend, so basically who was imagining this little girl that did not exist? I guess Emma was the aborted child? what about the imaginary husband who she thought was cheating on her.I just don't know I am sure I am making anyone more confused with my question. If anyone can help out and explain this movie that ended up leaving me clueless I would really appreciate it.
Don't read any further unless you are prepared for spoilers. The only scene that takes place in the present is the scene in the rest room. The other stuff is either flashbacks of the growing friendship between Diana and Maureen, or Diana's imagined future flashing before her eyes as she wrestles with her conscience in the rest room. And if you watch the flashbacks you can see the process of Diana becoming less and less selfish; a maturing that makes it difficult for her to allow Maureen to sacrifice her life so that Diana can live.
Emma does not represent the aborted child but rather the child that Diana imagined that she would conceive "responsibly" had Maureen been the one who was killed. She and Maureen had picked out girls' names together very early in the film, when they were imagining their future lives.
When watching movies like these, you HAVE to pay attention. The 2nd poster explained it in a very simple way.
Okay, so we see Diana's life as an adult. What we don't realize until the end of film, is that all of this was just an imagination. The movie continuously goes back to the bathroom where it leads to Diana making her final decision, for a reason. She was sort of looking at her life in the future. (which makes the title of the movie straight to the point). This is how her life would have been if she wouldn't have sacrificed her life.
Now if you notice, her life as an adult is pretty miserable. She has an enormous amount of guilt. She also doesn't trust her husband, who she thinks is cheating on her, because she sees him walking down the street with a young girl. Now I must admit, that part did confuse me a bit. I couldn't tell if that was supposed to be an older Emma walking with him, or Diana herself... since she met him when she was a teenager. (He made a speech at her high school one day).
The young Diana can forsee this miserable life. This feeling of guilt that she will have for the rest of her life, if she does not do what is right.
Now, this "new" Diana only makes such a tough decision to give up her life, because several events have matured her greatly, and we can definitely see the difference in her attitude leading up to the day. The abortion for one. Now let me make something clear... the aborted child is not Emma. This is also, another imagination. This is just young Diana imagining having the little girl that she always wanted. (we know this because she and Maureen are picking out their names for their future children). I couldn't tell if the young Diana was turing down the guy in that one scene, but I think she did, which is something that the old, out of control Diana would not have done. And lastly, the biggest reason that Diana makes her tough decision- is Maureen, herself. In a bunch of flashbacks, you see how close Maureen and Diana had become. Diana even questions why she was given such great friend like Maureen. Diana knew that she had to let Maureen live her life, because she knew that Maureen truly deserved it.
In the end, Emma runs away froms school. Diana is searching in the woods for her, but then Emma disappears. This only means one thing... time has caught up. The film is now in the present time again with Diana, Maureen and Michael Patrick in the bathroom. Diana makes her final decision to give up her life.
Maureen now has the perfect life that was miserable for Diana, because she deserved a life like this, and Diana gave it to her. Why? Because Maureen gave her what Diana appreciated the most, a true, loving friendship.
Then the film briefly goes back to the adult Diana taking flowers to the school- the woman asks her if she's a surivor, and she says no.
Umm..yeah! This is just my take on it, from watching the film a few times.
Live for today, not tomorrow, because tomorrow might be too late.
"all I know is that the ending totally confused the crap out of me."
Yeah lol
I thank you ShayMLovee for explaining it so in depth for us haha
I was confused by this though:
"I couldn't tell if the young Diana was turing down the guy in that one scene, but I think she did, which is something that the old, out of control Diana would not have done."
What scene was that?
I was also confused when the girl asked Uma Therman
"Are You A Survivor?"
- Umm... Unless we're suppose to believe that the girl could see dead people, how would she see her? Are we suppose to think the girl was talking to a ghost? Or was the girl who asking Uma that just another part of teen Diana's imagination?
I kinda felt guilty at the end of the movie, cause all along I was thinking,
"Jeeze why couldnt the good one have lived"
so I was kinda glad when Maureen turned out to be the one who lived in the end...
But uh I kinda wanted to explore the psychology of the killer a little more. I know that wasnt the point of this movie but I just wanted to know what led him to commit such a horrible inhumane crime.
The girl who was talking to adult Diana was all a part of teen Diana's imagination. The easiest way to understand it is just to assume that everything you saw with Uma Thurman was Evan Rachel Wood's imagination before she is shot. None of it actually happens (although I'm sure they would have a memorial ceremony later).
Thank you for explaining this. I was confused by the ending, though it was trying to sort itself out in my mind. I realized something more was happening here, because when the girl asked if she was one of the survivors she said "no".
I must say I didn't have it all figured out until reading what everyone else had to say. Just to add something to the idea that Diana is the one that died in the end: Don't forget about that scene (I think it was near the end) when Diana's mother rushes up to the school and screams "Diana!" I think they probably have told her that Diana was shot/killed.