MovieChat Forums > Appaloosa (2008) Discussion > Horrible Western!!!

Horrible Western!!!

posted 14 years ago by Galactus03
6 replies | jump to latest

Im a huge western fan. Seen all the great western films. Had high hopes for this one. With the good reviews it had gotten I was excited to see it. I would rather watch episodes of Bonanza, Gunsmoke, Wagon Train etc. that I have seen several times, than this piece of crap. It had an uninteresting plot/drama, barely any action.(which it wouldnt have needed much of if the plot didnt stink) This moive had nothing to offer a TRUE western fan.

For those who think this is better than the 3:10 to Yuma remake (or even the original) what the hell are you thinking. Theres no way true western fans liked this crap.

Open Range is also another recent western that beats this crap hands down. Even the long drawn out Wyatt Earp is better.

[–] samantha3 14 years ago

"Theres no way true western fan liked this crap."

You are simply proving once again that there are all kinds of "true western fans."

Some of those TWF's loved it.

Sorry you didn't, but that's the way it goes...

[–] Bilwick1 14 years ago

"Theres no way true western fan liked this crap."

Thank you, Captain Dogma. Well, as they say, there's no arguing with religion.

[–] slugdub 14 years ago

OP is spot on!

[–] Bry-2 13 years ago

What's the OP's idea of a "great Western"? Just curious.

I'm a fan of all the classic American Westerns (except High Noon - too much a 50s allegory for my taste), the Leones, Eastwood, Peckinpah ... and I liked this as a character-driven Western. It's certainly not typical, but I liked it a lot.

--If they move, kill 'em!

[–] liscarkat (18589) 10 months ago

OP is an idiot!

[–] MayaZD30 10 years ago

4/10