Rate the Seasons


I'm still watching the show but, so far, I rate the seasons - using a 10 star system (10 is best) - like this:

season 1 = 8 stars

season 2 = 5 stars

season 3.0 = 6 stars

season 3.5 = 7 stars

season 4.0 = 7 stars

season 4.5 = 8 stars ("Do You See What I See" = 10 stars)

season 5 = 9 stars

The Allison & Jack relationship should give the entire show a 0 or 1.

reply

Just finished season 4.0, it starts and ends fairly strong, I like the time travel bits, don't like what the show has been doing with characters' relationships.

I'd rate the beginning and end of season 4.0 with 8 stars but only 6 for the episodes in the middle, so I average it out with 7 stars.

How would you rate the seasons?

Also, a question about the 1st time travel event in the beginning of season 4, what happened to the version of the characters that disappeared, like the version of Henry that was actually married to Grace?

reply

Just saw the animated Christmas special. That one alone gets 10 stars.

reply

Overall, this is a good show, even great at times, yet the whole ordeal with Jack and Allison nearly ruins the show. They are one of the worst attempts for a couple in the history of television. Putting that aside, everything else is good stuff (so far, I still have to finish the final season, about 2/3 to 3/4 through it now).

reply

Finished watching it, updated original post. My ratings have an average of 7 (technically 7.14285714) but I went ahead and rated the entire series with an 8 on the main page for overall style and effect.

reply

I pretty much agree with your rating. I think the last season was by far the best, let's say a 9, season 4 - 8, season 3 - 5, season 2 - 5, season 1 - 7

reply