MovieChat Forums > Shutter (2008) Discussion > A Couple of Questions

A Couple of Questions


Ok - I've watched the movie, and I've got a couple of questions:

1) I'm totally confused about the timeline of Magumi's (the girl/ghost's) death. When they hit her in the road at the beginning of the movie, is she still alive, living her life, and is basically projecting herself into the photos, so she's totally unharmed because she's not actually, physically there? And if so, is she alive and going about her life during the first half of the movie, but messing with them as kind of an astral projection because she's so angry, etc? Or does she actually, physically get hit on the road, and die? Or was she dead before they came to Japan, and she's been messing with them as the ghost of a girl who's dead the whole time?


2) Is that Magumi sitting behind the reception desk in the office building when Ben first returns to work and introduces Jane to his friend? The second lady, sitting behind the desk - the one who makes eye contact with Jane. Is that her, or just someone who looks alot like her?

3) Why does the medium freak out at the sight of the photos?

Thanks in advance to anyone who can answer these!

reply

1) I'm thinking she killed herself a while ago; with the poison, because her body was so badly decomposed when they found it...she was in the wedding photos, so she was dead, i don't think anyone (namely magumi) was actually 'projecting' themselves while alive...they prob. just added that plot point as a possibility; to confuse us. I still can't figure out why she tried to kill, whatever her name was, in the bedroom--though.

2) No, i don't think that is her.

3) I think the medium, although i don't speak Japanese, must have muttered something about magumi specifically...bcuz, ben was so hell bent on the idea of going to him, and as soon as the medium flips out, he wants to leave.

I just saw the movie about ten mins ago...thats how i perceived it. I love Josh Jackson, but this movie really sucked bad

reply

The ghost wasn't trying to kill her but to warn/scare her to stay away from the guy. She said it herself.

reply

Question 1 has been answered very well!

For Question 2, no, that was not her.

For Question 3, he can tell what Ben did to the girl and I guess feel her pain as well.


Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work. -Edison

reply