Was Mac always gay, even in the earlier seasons? - It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia (2005) Discussion

[–] user-840-931683 9 years ago

Yes, it's always implied. Many clues were shown in previous seasons.

1) He dated a guy before he did transgender surgery.

2) He has daddy issue, which is a strong indicator of gayness.

3) S5E6, he wrote a lover letter to a famous baseball player.

Many many others.

I would make love to him. He is sexy.

reply

[–] jnatch 9 years ago

lol you really are exaggerating some of these descriptions to back up your hypothesis

reply

[–] Jaynes_hat 8 years ago

1) did you see the guy? if more trannys looked exactly like the dirty one out of the sweet valley twins you could define my sexuality how you want.

2) ignorant on many levels

3) more childish than anything else

reply

[–] elce26 9 years ago

The "bicep" invitation to the party mansion. Nothing sexual.

reply

[–] CHplanb 8 years ago

In the first season, he tried to get one of his old teachers (a male teacher) to blow him.

reply

[–] Near-L 8 years ago

Mac clearly have attraction for both genders, he sure enjoyed banging Dennis mom and that religious freak in season 1, he would be a bisexual in my opinion but he is even more complicated than that. I wouldn't think about it that much, pretty much everything the gang do is whatever they feel like at the moment, and it variates from time to time like atoms. You can't really label something that changes constantly.

Bad people protecting good people by killing worse people.

reply

[–] BronnFlakes 8 years ago

There have been hints throughout the ENTIRE series. That article is a little poor, since it seems to think that Mac being gay is a new aspect of his character.

reply

[–] ardinsalim 8 years ago

he bang the tranny and try to get molested by his gym teacher in season 1. it save to say he's already have "that' charcteristic early in the series

reply

[–] ehheSpeepe 8 years ago

Him banging the tranny and trying to get the gym teacher to feel him up were not signs of him being gay, they were examples of him being so extremely vain that he would desperately take attention from anyone willing to give it

reply

[–] everydayboredom1980 8 years ago

Yeah, I agree, those weren't really about Mac's preference, those instances were about his ego and vanity.

The humor in the Mr. Belding thing was not that Mac really wanted him, but the lengths of how far he will go to satisfy his own ego and insecurities.

The thing with Carmen was that she complimented his looks. At first he was disappointed when he found out Carmen is a dude, saying "you lied to me", but as soon as she complimented his physique, he started liking Carmen.

Again, the joke is how vain he is, his whole look on everything changed once she talked about how "ripped" he is.

And also there's the fact that Brittany Daniel is pretty hot.

reply

[–] BigDDD 8 years ago

Him banging the tranny and trying to get the gym teacher to feel him up were not signs of him being gay, they were examples of him being so extremely vain that he would desperately take attention from anyone willing to give it

Loooolz sure. Go around telling yourself that trying to get men to blow you and getting sexual with a preop tranny are not signs of you being gay and are just because you're really vain😂😂😂

reply

[–] SFSorrow66 8 years ago

Mac is Gay. But he's not. He is but he isn't. Why is this confusing?

reply

[–] KingCobra686 8 years ago

Whatever it is, hes got something going on that makes him feel like he needs to overcompensate with showing off his masculinity. It could be that hes gay and doesnt want to admit it, or it could be something else.

reply