MovieChat Forums > El orfanato (2008) Discussion > Scene that freaked me out the most (SPOI...

Scene that freaked me out the most (SPOILERS)


When she walks out into the shed the middle of the night and sees Benigna just creeping around. Holy crap!


- - -

reply

haha that scene actually made me and everyone I was watching it with laugh cause Benigna looks so crazy and funny

reply

You're right benigna is weird XD

but the scene who give me the freaks is where Laura play with the children in the middle of the night at the game "one, two, tree..." and she return each time!

reply

The 2nd "knock on the wall" scene?- that's a great scene for sure. Everything about that shot gives the scene a sense of tension: the slightly handheld quality of the camerawork, the pacing, the silouettes, the absense of music- when I saw this at the cinema the audience was deathly silent, you could hear a pin drop.

For me the creepiest scene has to be where Simon tells Laura that he's "not going to grow up"- as the conversation proceeds, Laura and the audience slowly begin to realise that Simon knows more than he's admitting to, and more than Laura wants him to know. I just find it really unsettling the way he skillfully picks at her guilt for keeping secrets from him, in order to gauge whether she will continue to deceive him. Plus I always found the concept behind the story of Peter Pan more than a little disturbing

reply

Yes, i mean the 2nd "Knock on the wall" scene. The scene where simon said he not going to grow up is a freaky scene too.

The realisation of the movie is magic, the spectator can feel every scene just by the dark atmosphere in the house. I Think El Orfanato is the first "long time" movie of the director Juan Antonio Bayona i wonder is next movie was a success too.

reply

True, this is his first full length film. I read somewhere that Bayona was planning to do more horror. I also read that a couple of years ago he was approached by execs to do the next twilight movie which he turned down (thank lord). Whatever he does, I hope Sergio Sanchez (El Orfanato's screenplay writer) is on board

reply

I'm agree with you, ALL but not twilight! I Did'nt see it but i think is not my genre of movie.

You have seen a many greatly film recently ?

reply

Nah, I've not seen any of the twilight movies, either. "Let the right one in" is more my kind of vampire film.

reply

I Always hesitated to buy "Let the right one in", he worth it ?

reply

I'd recommend RENTING the movie just in case you see it and don't like it. There's a similarity to the Orphanage in that there's 2 ways to interpret the film particularly the outcome for the two main characters by the end of the movie- people have vastly differing views on how the film should be interpretated which I find compelling. LTROI is also a very creepy, unsettling film and at times very brutal.

reply

Worth it if you watch the Swedish one. Many people preferred the American version, but I think the ambiguities in the Swedish version make for a much better film.

reply

It was the knock knock knock on the wall game in the dark that gave me shivers. When she was holding what she thought was Simon in the blanket before she saw things as they really were, I got freaked, too. I was like, 'WTF! That can't really be her kid. What is it?!' Didn't like the sack mask, either. Even when Simon drew the kid in it, I thought it was freaky. And the dying medium's visit was pretty scary, too. I could go on, but I guess I just liked the movie...

Definitely watch 'Let The Right One In'. If you want something original and different from the usual vampire flick. The American remake 'Let Me In' is better than most remakes, too. It makes a couple of points a bit clearer than they do in the original. Both versions are great IMHO

reply

Yeah, those scenes were definitely scary. However I found the most unpleasant one to be the scene where Benigna gets run over. You don't except the car to come at all, and when she's lying on the street with her jaw all messed up.. Jikes. Didn't make it better when she suddenly grasped Laura's wrist :) I don't usually mind gore, but that was just too much.

The mask is definitely scary too. The anxiety and anticipation of what's beneath killed me. I had expected him to be much more deformed, though. Wearing a mask all the time because of how he looked (scars and weird eyes, I believe? Not really much worse than Heath Ledger's The Joker imo) seemed a bit overexaggerated. However, Benigna didn't seem too well either, so I guess that has something to do with it..

reply

Yeah, Benigna! Totally gross. I agree that it was over the top in a story that played on atmosphere and plot; a real ghost story that made you think, not a gore fest.

The mask was just horrible, poor little kid.

They're coming to get you, Barbra!

reply

I have to agree with you on this one! This one REALLY freaked me out. I actually thought it was the ghost of an old man with a gun in his hand. Until I realized though that it was Benigna and I think the funny part was the way she was running away from the shed. Lol.

reply

Haha I know, Benigna both freaks me out and makes me laugh.

reply

I literally gasped out loud.

reply

I found it most scary when you see a child in the mask staring at Laura before he pushes her

reply