I think it would have be neat if Agent Henriksen survived longer and became Same and Deans inside guy at the FBI, someone who can help out sometimes and maybe toss a few cases their way. https://supernatural.fandom.com/wiki/Victor_Henriksen granted his death made quite an impact though as you didnt see it coming after all that occured in his final episode.
shareBelphegor, the demon that possessed Jack's body.
Uriel.
I would agree with Henriksen and Uriel.
I would also go along with Balthazar, Azazel, Adam, the original Death and Cain. So many great characters to think about I get lost.
Robert Wisdom was a great actor for the role of Uriel! I had forgotten the character it had been so long but once I saw a photo I remembered how good the actor was for the role!
shareBoth Robert and Kurt Fuller were the best match and one of the best castings of the series.
shareOh Kurt Fuller nailed it outta the park, a guy you loved to hate! Such charisma to that role.
I liked Balthazar and the actor playing him as well, it was tragic how he died in the show. We barely got Adam and it was a gut punch when it turned out our first meeting him was acutally a ghoul.
I always found it funny how the early season characters seemed to be short lived while the later season characters overstayed their welcome and were kept on too long.
I would pick Julian Richings as Death (only 5 episodes) could've done so much more with him.
Also Ellen, Garth, Rufus, and should've used Robert Englund as a recurring character and not just a one off.
I could never see fans interest in Garth, he was one of those characters like Claire who really annoyed me in the end. I think he was over used. But, yes, to Ellen Rufus and Robert England he should have had way more screen time than he got.
shareI think it was neat that Garth became a werewolf. It showed that the hunters faced more problems than just death. Usually it still meant a death sentence like when Gordon became a vampire. But this time it showed a hunter living with it and remaining good.
I think Garth is loved because he is more relatable and its also funny. This lanky goofy guy is a badass who fights monsters. People hated/loved his character on Z Nation where he played Citizen Z but I liked him in that as well. (I noticed I keep mentioning Z Nation lately xD I miss watching that show)
The creators said they introduced Ellens bar as a place Sam and Dean can go to hangout and meet hunters but that "it didnt work" so they had the bar burned down. Im thinking we would have seen Ellen a lot more if they held onto the original idea. I thought Ellens Bar was alright, its barely shown xD it could have worked if the creators made it feel like an actual bar instead of a ghost town where Ellen, Her Daughter Jo, and the sleeping Mullet Genius Ash stayed at.
I loved Rufus, his chemistry with Bobby was fun. However his death and his last words with Bobby were harsh! But I reckon it taught a lesson. Dont leave bad mojo with people. Try to patch things are just forgive...its hard though, at times. Even I make this mistake and recently as well I've done this as well!
You have a good point that they killed off people real quick early on, and others they kept. But some of these keepers were awesome! Sheriffy Jody Mills and her character growth. Sheriff Donna Hanscum being another! Also Jack becoming a main cast member was great and fun!