Better or Worse than the 2019 remake

This one is not as good as the 2019 version.

i thought the 2019 version played like its script had been written by a bot that had been fed a year of intersectional twitter threads. it's really silly & not very well executed imo, but i think it has a goofily incompetent energy that makes it fun to watch.

i haven't seen the 2006 version, but i see it just popped up on tubitv, so i might give it a go tonight.

The 2006 one is miles better, outside of the two killer's and ridiculous backstory of the killers, the 2006 movie is pretty good, i love the colors in that movie and how it looks. The 2006 one while its not perfect looked and felt creative, this ones just boring and generic as fuck.

Both 2006 and 2019 were vastly inferior to 1974, so I'd have a hard time picking either.

I'd probably give the nod to 2006 though. Because, I can at least see the point to it from the perspective of it being a remake. 2006 was basically for people who didn't like the ambiguity of the 1974 movie. 1974 BC left you not seeing the killer, and not knowing a hell of a lot about Billy's motivations. You had to piece together what you could about his ramblings about Billy. If you want a film that explains everything and ties it all together, watch the latter. Also, 2006 seemed to follow what a millennial horror movie was like. Putting in graphic/shock moments rather than slowly setting up suspense. I personally much preferred 1974, but that's the point. People tend to prefer one or the other, because they're the same-ish story, but aiming it at a different audience. Sort of feels like the point of a remake.

2019, I'm sure they meant well, and was trying for a feminist message. But I didn't feel it was done to well, and really there was no point to it being a Black Christmas remake. It had very little to do with the original, and could've just been called something else.

Saying that, if done properly 2019 maybe could've been better than 2006.

Lol BC 2006 is a few notches above the latest remake .. the newest one was woke and just dull and pointless

Way better than the 2019 version. No it isn't as good as the original, but it's pretty decent in it's own right.

2019 doesn't have anything redeemable about it.