MovieChat Forums > Black Christmas (2006) Discussion > I liked this a lot more than the origina...

I liked this a lot more than the original.


I also posted this on the original's board:

I respect everyone's opinions, because opinions are the way we feel about something and we can't help how we feel. I feel like the 2006 remake of "Black Christmas" was much better than the '70s film. While the original was enjoyable for its nostalgic tone and retro atmosphere, to me, it wasn't impactful to the least bit, and the majority of the film was quite forgettable. It was extremely slow and it felt like it was never going to get intriguing. I'm not saying that I'm an ADD movie-goer who only wants to see action (in fact, I hate most car chase and explosion scenes in movies)--I can handle a slow build-up if the premise or execution is enjoyable (and of course the pay-off has to be satisfying). The point of movies are to entertain, and this film only did that to small extent.

However, the remake was fast-paced, intriguing, creepy, fun, and the atmosphere was pure perfection. The film felt very Christmassy, but at the same time, there was a dark tone that blended beauty with sinister elements. The visuals were just absolutely stunning, there were somewhat powerful overlooked themes of family, cool death scenes, and some excellent performances from most of the cast. I absolutely loved the direction and execution, and am extremely sad to see people who hate this film so aggressively, calling it "one of the worst films ever" when honestly, I think it is one of the best horror movies in the past decade. There were some minor flaws, but those flaws didn't define the movie as a whole.

I can understand if fans of the original were upset about some things, but I see the film as an undeniable improvement over the original. Do people just bash it because its a remake, because it seems that people judge something automatically without an open mind. The point of a remake is to expose an entirely new audience to an amazing story that they may not have heard of, and present it to them with all of the modern advances in technology and storytelling. It's kind of like passing a classic story down from generation to generation--there may be some major changes or improvements to the story, but the overall idea stays intact to entertain individuals who aren't familiar with it.

reply

I preferred the remake over the original. Even without those infamous trailer only scenes this film is a fantastic slasher. Really nasty in places too. And an entire cast of wonderful actresses.

reply

While the original is one of my favorite horror movies ever, there ARE things about this that I enjoy more than the 1974 version, so I can totally see why someone would like this better. With that said, I just love both ;P

reply

Liked the original better, but really enjoyed this remake as well. Both are great in their respective ways.











"Speak of the Devil, and He shall appear."

reply

I also think that this movie is way better than the original, the original was boring as sh!t, this remake wasn't boring to me at all.

reply

The original was always be a favorite of mine. The characters were enchanting.

reply