MovieChat Forums > Black Christmas (2006) Discussion > IF ONLY Mary Elizabeth Winstead took the...

IF ONLY Mary Elizabeth Winstead took the lead role....


I think this movie would've been 10 times better. Even if it was the same exact movie. I like Katie Cassidy but I think Mary would've made a more likeable lead. Plus she looked gorgeous in this! I wish she wouldn't died!

reply

Lacey Chabert should have had the lead role.

reply

I think Mary would've done a great job in the lead. I wished that her & Michelle didn't die. But I was glad that Katie's character lived!

"I am the ultimate badass, you do not wanna `*beep*` wit' me!" Hudson in Aliens.

reply

Lacey Chabert should have had the lead role.


Seconded.

reply

Lacey was funny in this. I find Katie Cassidy boring as hell, so any change there would have been fine with me.

reply

I liked her as Heather.

reply

The first time I saw the movie, I thought her character was going to be the heroine, especially when she investigates Eve's room and finds the newspaper clippings. This was actually one of the few movies where is honestly did not know who would survive.

reply

Me too, I thought she was gonna be the heroine, it's hard to figure out who was gonna make it out alive.

"I am the ultimate badass, you do not wanna `*beep*` wit me!"- Hudson in Aliens.

reply

another reason to love this film, with all the girls being "named stars" you never knew for sure who was going to live and die, also Kudos to Michelle and Mary for wanting their characters to die.

reply

[deleted]

Katie Cassidy usually can't act

reply

[deleted]

I would have prefered MEW as the lead too.

reply

Movie definitely would have been better with more MEW.

reply

[deleted]