MovieChat Forums > The Giver (2014) Discussion > Divergent + Equilibrium = The Giver

Divergent + Equilibrium = The Giver


Like the title suggests, The Giver is just a mash-up of a couple of other movies, primarily Divergent and Equilibrium. Also a bit of Pleasantville in there too. Not nearly as original as it probably thinks it is. It's just another future dystopia aimed at the teen market. Nice try Harvey Weinstein.

reply

The Giver was written well before any of those.

Just because you understand the mechanics of how something works doesn't make it any less of a miracle

reply

Not knocking the author of the book, but from a strictly movie point of view, the comparison holds true. Didn't see anything in The Giver that I hadn't seen on screen before, much of it fairly recently.

Obviously Hollywood is still trying to cash in on the whole teen future dystopian crazy, kicked off by the Hunger Games and Divergent. Without the current fad, it's unlikely The Giver would have even been made at this point. Just saying.

reply

[deleted]

False, because it isn't a mashup of those since it came before them. They're likely the one ripping off The Giver.

reply

This was exactly what I was thinking! Felt like a mash up of Equilibrium, Divergent, and Pleasantville. All great films too, including this one. I liked it. Although it was too short but it's fine.

reply

Like the title suggests, The Giver is just a mash-up of a couple of other movies, primarily Divergent and Equilibrium. Also a bit of Pleasantville in there too.


The Giver's source material predated all of those works.

Not nearly as original as it probably thinks it is.


It's just that these dystopian tales have similar, universal themes, hence the similarities.

And this movie is original; it just isn't novel.

Nice try Harvey Weinstein.


What? Why is it so important for people to be know-it-alls and defiantly act that they couldn't or wouldn't get sucked into the story?

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

Divergent nor Equilibrium made me react emotionally like The Giver has. I enjoyed all three movies but see them differently.

reply