MovieChat Forums > Binjip (2004) Discussion > question for the people who saw this mov...

question for the people who saw this movie


i'd like to see this movie with my family, but i was wondering if there's an act of suicide in it (sensitive subject in my family at the moment..)

reply

No.

reply

No there is not. But I warn you this is high art movie and can be found as boring for unexperienced person.

reply

agreed but the movie has some high emotional situations...it is a very good movie though i enjoyed it

reply

IMHO one of the best movies I have ever seen, but still not enjoyable for everybody.

reply

I found it too openly metaphorical.

I'm not saying it's bad, it just tries too hard to make a point and ultimately fails to be coherent, unlike David Lynch's films or Kitano's "Dolls". "Dolls" is much better at being metaphorical, it works because it's not over-the-top metaphorical and the metaphors go along with the main story.

Still, 3 Iron can be an enjoyable movie for some, but it didn't work very well for me. I gave it a 6/10 because, despite the overall feeling if incoherence, it does have some good ideas and a decent cinematography.




This... is chemical burn.

reply



yeah, cos i was wondering is the sexual content a bit too much? since i'm not really old enough (16) and i really dun wanna see all that anyway.

reply

[deleted]

I thought this was original and fascinating. I was a little surprised at the casting but it worked well. Let's hope Hollywood stays WELL AWAY before yet another outstanding idea gets over-cooked.

I'm sick of being the one that eats bugs and gets the funny syphillis

reply