Ira Hayes


Too bad Rudy Youngblood didn't play Ira Hayes. I think he looks like him. I didn't really care for Adam Beach as Hayes. I saw an old movie from 1961 called The Outsider all about Ira Hayes. Tony Curtis, who is obviously not a real Indian, played him. Curtis had some great moments in the movie. I thought he was better than Adam Beach. Rudy Youngblood is a good actor. I wonder how he would've been as Ira Hayes. I haven't seen him in anything accept Apocalypto. Too bad Apocalypto didn't come out sooner than Flags of Our Fathers. Rudy Youngblood would've been known at the time.

reply

I detested the movie depiction of Marine Private Ira Hayes, played by Adam Beach. Ira Hayes is portrayed as a crybaby who is torn inwardly with a personal ethical dilemna that he feels pressure to lie and be deceitful in 'pretending' to be a big hero. Ira Hayes just didn't get it. The American government was asking for his 'help' in winning the war by helping to raise additional badly needed government revenues. The U.S. government was fast running out of cash. The next step would be either to print more paper money or start liquidating the nation's gold reserves, neither a viable alternative. One of Ira's colleagues doesn't like it either, but understand's the country's need for heroes and so cooperates. The other colleague loves his hero role and enjoys every moment. Ira Hayes in the movie cannot come to terms with his huge dislike of what he feels is playing a false hero. So he succumbs to alcoholism and bad behavior. This also played badly into the stereotype of Native Americans and alcohol addiction. Ira Hayes years later is found lying face down off the side of a road on the Indian reservation, lifeless. Of course Ira Hayes didn't deserve this fate. He could have done far, far better, but it was all up to him. He chose.

reply

Are you talking about Adam Beach or Ira Hayes?

Do you have any information that was inaccurate about Hayes in this movie?

I think your problem is with the real man, not with the character.

reply

I'm with leisureman. I'm a bit confused as to if you're objecting to Adam Beach's performance or Ira Hayes as a real man. Ira never set out to be a hero. As he said, he was just trying not to get shot. Whatever the stereotypes of Native Americans, Ira had a drinking problem. He wasn't the only one to survive these circumstances and wind up the same way. Ryan Phillippe, who played Doc, has said his own grandfather, who was decorated for his service in Europe, also became an alcoholic after the war. Ira succumbed to his demons and that's as trajic as the battlefield slaughters.

RIP Ira Hayes.



"I'd never ask you to trust me. It's the cry of a guilty soul."

reply