MovieChat Forums > Down in the Valley (2005) Discussion > why edward why????????

why edward why????????

posted 18 years ago by portugal123
12 replies | jump to latest

why did u did this movie omg u are a genius one of the best actors in the world u dont need to do this kind of movie...... omg please think better next time.

[–] alyssaassyla 18 years ago

I hated it too. He was so irritating, I Just couldn't stand him. And one more thing, I couldn't stop thinking that he's like Woody from the Toy Story!!!

[–] mpc64 18 years ago

ignorant fools

[–] 18 years ago

[deleted]

[–] vervefan-1 17 years ago

--- mpc64 said:

ignorant fools---

---terry-webdesign said:

I can understand that fans are disapointed, but you need to be open minded---

Did either of you two see the South Park episode where the character based upon Michael Jackson kept accusing everyone of ignorance when they disagreed with his action? That's what this reminds me of.

I think this was a bad film, plain and simple. However it was just a movie, not an issue of social prejudice or any other comparable issue, so please don't think my view is based upon being "ignorant" or needing to be "open minded". Contrary to what you appear to believe, it is possible for people to dislike without having such character flaws.

---panterken said:

Norton is called a sell-out for doing films like Down In The Valley---

By who? Not by anyone in this thread, so if you're going to defend him, try to stick to answering criticisms that have been made, rather than just ones that nobody here has brought up.

[–] sindaanca1 18 years ago

Thanks Edward. This movie was worth your genius and your career!

[–] Zeeshopper 17 years ago

I can understand that fans are disapointed, but you need to be open minded. The story was alright, but Edward's acting (like all the other actors) was outstanding and that is what took the movie to a upper level.

[–] jennellexoxo 17 years ago

this movie was amazing, what is wrong with you people?

[–] SamanthaWho88 17 years ago

It's a great film!

It's my second greatest performance of his behind American History X

*I saw in your eyes that you hate the world, I hate it too...*

[–] Panterken 17 years ago

Quote: mpc64

"ignorant fools"

Amen! Norton is called a sell-out for doing films like Down In The Valley & The Painted Veil. I admire him for taking the time to do these small films. I'd call him a sell-out if he'd only do only big-budget Hollywood films...Lord knows a lot of tasteful actors have lost their taste and sold their soul after a big Boxoffice hit.

>C.

[–] alkamal_r 17 years ago

Fight Club, Primal Fear?

Ironically, this isn't even ironic at all.

[–] walking_bread 17 years ago

Norton had more invested in this film than his acting performance. He is one of the producers of the film meaning he footed some of the bill, which was probably north of a million dollars of his own money.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]