MovieChat Forums > Derailed (2005) Discussion > No father would sacrifice the life of hi...

No father would sacrifice the life of his Daughter


I understand the concept of blackmailing a man and the risk of losing his wife or family being at stake. I can even imagine there's some men who would go above and beyond what most consider "too much" in order to keep their adulterous actions hidden. I even could believe a man, driven into depression and lacking emotional connection from his daughter's life threatening illness could make such a selfish, thoughtless, and disgusting momentary lapse in their judgement.

What I find extremely difficult to understand is a FATHER that would risk his daughters life to save his name, marriage and the life of a female whom he'd only recently begun this so called "affair" (for lack of a better term). The two never even actually had intercourse, so I'm not sure what made the risk in telling his wife so much worse the truth being hidden at the expense of her life. If I was his wife, I'd of had less respect for him for telling me that seven years of the couple saving money for their daughter's extended lifespan, than a husband who almost cheated. Only to tell her the entire story immediately after he'd paid the blackmailer.

A father would never risk his daughters life for the sake of his good name let alone for some woman whom he'd "almost" had an affair with one time. I'm a mother myself, and I know the thought process of a parent, and this is too much of a stretch for me to believe.

reply

You should add in the word 'decent' or 'good'

A GOOD father wouldn't do it, a DECENT father would put his daughter first but not EVERY father would do it. There are many selfish fathers out there who usually put themselves before everyone else, including their kids. Hence why we have so many men who walk out on their kids or beat/neglect them.

And Charles was somewhat selfish in his own way, ok very selfish for giving all his daughters money over. Hes a dad, he loved his daughter but he was clearly not a very good dad. A decent dad would never do that, a decent husband would never cheat...






Ashmi any question

reply

You're absolutely correct. I can honestly say that my concept and thought process would never have even considered that a parent or father would act in such a selfish manner. However, I've been very blessed with a husband who'd risk his entire life in order to save our daughter, our son or even myself from just feeling any pain. It's very easy to take for granted something that seems so natural, so relatable when I'd do the same for them without hesitation. But unfortunately there are a large number, entirely too large, of father AND mothers who's children will never be their number one. I am embarrassed at how my post came off so naive and sheltered, completely ignorant to a world without a white picket fence. But you are one hundred percent correct and I couldn't agree with you more. It even changes my perception of the movie's realistic storyline.

reply

he only handed over the $100k when he actually came to the house and threatened the daughter. it wasnt for lucindas marriage

reply

It has been a few weeks since I have watched this movie but I was under the impression that it wasn't after he had come to their home that he'd first given the blackmailer money. I remember him giving them money prior to this also, but again it has been a while so I cannot say positively.

reply