MovieChat Forums > CSI: NY (2004) Discussion > (SPOILER -SOME) The girlfriend....

(SPOILER -SOME) The girlfriend....

posted 12 years ago by ldddhunter
3 replies | jump to latest

of the young man who was killed was so classy how she went out in front of the mob outside the police station and spoke so TRUE about what happened... she was VERY brave to say what she did - even if some of them didn't like it. She spoke from her heart and EVERYTHING she said was true - it was those 2 thugs who decided to rob that store and they are to blame for what happened that day. I feel bad for the victim's family and the police officer who shot the kid. He will live w/this for the rest of his life and its gonna haunt him as well..he was truly upset for what happened. That one guy who jo shot deserved to die, bc he's one of the thugs (he was reaching for his gun from the mailbox), and the other one bluntly came out and said he was gunning for the cop, so he deserves a LONG time in prison, he acted as if they were suppose to feel sorry for him. They used that gun anytime they wanted, it was like there for them anytime they needed it (the thug even said it himself). Him and his dead friend are the REAL cause of this whole tragedy...

[–] ritamilo 12 years ago

OMG that was amazing: too bad life can't imitate art sometimes. To see someone in a real life equivalent of that situation respond in that manner would be a huge step forward for humankind.

English MA: Symbolism/my life. Truth vs the world - Boudicca of the Iceni

[–] Renny085 12 years ago

I did appreciate that the writers did not have her character immediately forgive the cop, I thought that was believeable and honest.

Save a life, adopt a homeless pet!

[–] Luna713 12 years ago

I thought the whole episode (despite the cliche of white-cop-shoots-black-kid) was extremely well written and heartbreaking. It had me in--or on the verge of--tears for most of the latter half of the episode. Really good writing, imho. You can't not feel sorry for both the girlfriend and the officer, because like she said, he has to live with this for the rest of his life.