MovieChat Forums > The Black Dahlia (2006) Discussion > I guess I'm the only one...

I guess I'm the only one...

posted 16 years ago by MarieGL
49 replies | jump to latest

Apparently im the only one who thought it was a good movie?
- And the only one who thought Josh Hartnett wasn't wrong for this role?
It was a good movie, I'm not saying it was great or the best, but interesting and the acting was good. I thought Josh was really good as Bucky and played him well.
Well, I'm fine with being a minority :) But let me know if anyone else liked this.
Oh..Josh - You are hot... I had to be said :)

"It's your life...Go live it"

[–] samdevil 16 years ago

I like it. It was a nice movie if you are bored and there's nothing on tv.It was a good distracction. Besides, the photography, music, costumes and sets were incredibly beautiful.

[–] kidconte-1 16 years ago

I just watched it for the 1st time yesterday. and i agree with you, it wasn't too bad. it was interesting, and it kept my attention, even tho in the begining i was wondering if it would ever get to the murder case.
but overall i didn't think that it was too bad!
so i am joining the minority group with you. :)

[–] StephEff 16 years ago

I really enjoyed it. I just watched it now because I'm on a Scarlett Johansson movie marathon lately and I seem to be renting every movie with her in it lately, but I thought it was beautifully shot, the costumes were gorgeous, the story was interesting, and for those who say they couldn't follow it, I'd recommend turning on the subtitles. The only thing that bothered me was the mumbling, but that seems to happen a lot lately, so I automatically turn on subtitles nowadays.

Much love and BIG KISSES,
Steph

Warning: I SPAM

PERKELE!!!

[–] dalldorfw 11 years ago

"The only thing that bothered me was the mumbling, but that seems to happen a lot lately, so I automatically turn on subtitles nowadays."

I hear that! So many movies now are hard to follow because everyone barely whispers under their breath, meanwhile all the sound effects are cranked up to the point where someone coming his/her hair sounds like a nuclear war (so far, I think 'Stoker' is the worst when it comes to that). I don't know why that's a trend now, but I blame Brando.

[–] newt_jorden 16 years ago

I did love that movie

[–] jmorrison-2 16 years ago

Nope, I enjoyed the movie also, and I even understood it. Although Josh Hartnett may not have the most range I've ever seen in an actor, he does a good job with the roles he's given. I thought he was very good in this, and I found it an interesting study of the characters involved.

See Josh in "Lucky Number Slevin" or "30 days of night". He does a great job in both.

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Rephraser 16 years ago

This movie is so good!
I love it!

So.. you are not the only one ;)

Greetings from Holland!

[–] Brysonashultz 16 years ago

I don't understand what was so difficult to understand about it.
Sure, it wasn't great, but SERIOUSLY...how can you say it was terrible or one of the worst movies ever made? That's just and ignorant statement. It was fun, I was entertained, it made me contemplate the actual murder, but it lacked that mise een scene (sp?) that's quite undefinable but makes the film.

6/10

"Long live the New Flesh!" - Videodrome

[–] The_Cackling_Stump 16 years ago

I enjoyed it; acting was great, especially by Hilary Swank. A refreshing dose of film noir in modern times.

"We're out of our medicine, out of our minds and we want in yours; let us in!"

[–] edwinomeara 15 years ago

I LOVED THIS MOVIE. ITS MY ALL TIME FAVOURITE MOVIE!!!!!!!!