MovieChat Forums > Green Street (2005) Discussion > What's the point of the fight?

What's the point of the fight?


So a bunch of guys say, "Ya know, this team of football players that doesn't know us but plays in our town a lot? They are so good that we need to fight other people who are also not connected in any way to the football teams that pay in their towns. Because football."

This makes no sense to me at all. If one person or two did it, I would chalk it up as mutual insanity. So how and why does this happen so often and with so many people?

I've heard that it gives some folks with little hope, a feeling of belonging. But even under those circumstances, I don't know if I'd base my kinship with non family members based on our mutual belief that coincidentally, the best football team in the world is from the same city we are living in, despite their win/loss record saying otherwise.

One might as well base their deep devotion to others that shop in the same grocery store because it carries by far the largest verity of grapes (Despite the fact that it does not), and we both need to physically attack anyone who disputes this non-fact.

reply

[deleted]

You sould watch Football Fight Club, a UK documentary available on Youtube, that's explains how it all started in the 70's...

It's not pure violence, you have to undestand it a an social aspect first.


IMO

reply

They'd argue that they don't "physically attack anyone who disputes this non-fact" - that they only fight with other "firms" who are consenting to a fight. They don't just attack supporters of other clubs who aren't involved.

Which would be fine if it wasn't for the fact that
(1) innocent people get caught up in it, either as by-standers who get hit, or being in the wrong place at the wrong time when some thug wants to assert his alpha status (such as the guy hatcher attacks in the chippy). And even if they don't get physically hit, they could still be scarred emotionally through being blamelessly caught up in the middle of it, such as the old guy reading a paper on the station platform at the beginning
(2) it means all football fans, in particular visiting fans, are treated as thugs by the police and the authorities
(3) the taxpayer funded NHS has to keep treating those who come worst off in these "rumbles", plus innocent locals have to live with the criminal damage these rumbles have caused until the council can fix it, then their council taxes have to foot the bill for repairs (like the toppled phone box from the opening fight)

So this idea that they only fight among each other so it's harmless is absolute bs.

reply