MovieChat Forums > American Pastoral (2016) Discussion > Horrible last parts of the movie

Horrible last parts of the movie


I liked this movie but holy moley, the ending was horrible. Why the *beep* did he not just knock her ass out and get her to jail instead of leaving her in that dump? Its obvious she had lost her mind and could not think reasonably. *beep* idiot character Ewan played, i would have forced her to come home since she clearly was not sane and needed help or at least send her to prison where she would have gotten a much more normal life then that dump and dumb ideas in her head...

No way i would have let my daughter stay in a dump like that, so this ending really screwed the movie over for me

reply

I was thinking the same too. I'd rather my daughter was in prison and being helped. Also, they had money and so could have hired a good lawyer to plead insanity or something, in case they had the death penalty.

reply

Yes exactly!! I'm glad at least i was not the only one who thought this! I would never allow my daughter to live like that even if she said she wanted too!

reply

Merry turned into some kind of zombie after she ran away from home. What is with the mask she was wearing?

reply

Different town, different insanity: This time it was Jainism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jainism

reply

I totally agree!

reply

They didn't have "disassociative disaffective disorders" back then. People were just plain crazy. He was a desperate man and prior to this, everything he touched turned to gold. In the book, the wife actually leaves him for a college professor, Swede remarries and has sons, but he never brings himself to give up on Merry. It's his mortal failing.

The reason she's wearing that mask is because she has turned to Jainism, which is entirely too much for me to explain, other than to say it's similar to what Gandhi practiced. She has become remorseful of her actions, and in her possible mental illness, perhaps feels this will absolve her for what she has done.

reply

So the ending was horrible because the character didn't act like you would? Do you judge all movies based on how closely the characters resemble your personal thoughts and actions? You must not enjoy films a lot.

That being said, the movie was just awful altogether.

reply

[deleted]

I know. He never really tried to save her the entire movie. He was always emotionally unavailable to his family. That's why all that bad stuff happened to him. He only cared about his company and his employees.

reply

I read the book, and am watching the movie now, so I kind of already know what happens.


I wanted to smack Swede the whole way through the book for being so clueless and out of touch!





AVADA KEDAVRA!!!

reply

He was always emotionally unavailable to his family.


He was? The movie didn't bring this across for me, not at all!

We see plenty of scenes where he is a loving and caring father. Talks to her sensibly and sensitive, and respects (and redoubts) her crazy ideas even as a teenager. He was portrayed as the opposite of an unemotional father.

reply

You think that he was too emotionally available to her?

reply