MovieChat Forums > A Cinderella Story (2004) Discussion > Sam vs Shelby. Who is hotter?

Sam vs Shelby. Who is hotter?



I love Shelby

reply

Shelby may have looked better on the outside...but it was sam who was better on the inside...I mean when you are ugly on the inside it shows you're ugly on the outside and even though sam wasn't as good looking as Shelby I believed she looked better.

reply

shelby was gorgeous. In real life she would have got the guy over sam 100% of the time.

I feel sorry for people who dont drink
wake up in the morning and thats the best they feel all day

reply

Shelby didnt look better on the outside .. (: lol
I love Sam. (:

reply

I liked Sam

reply

I like Sam better, because Shelby looked, well, like a typical, clique girl...

reply

[deleted]

Shelby is gorgeous,but, I don't see where she is hotter than Sam..They are both gorgeous...Sam was very pretty and gorgeous too.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Sam all the way! She was not only prettier, but she has a good heart and that's always sexy ;)

reply

I thought Sam was waaaay prettier. Hilary Duff looks great in this movie.

reply

I'd have to go with Shelby. The word hot to me seems to be about physical attractiveness only.

If they had to play the MFK game for this movie, Sam is the person you'd marry because she had a better all around package. Shelby is the one that people would want to *beep* because to some that is all a hot chick is worth. Of course we would kill off Fiona for the K option.

reply

Shelby is definitely more beautiful.

reply

Sam is much hotter. Hilary Duff used to be my #1 celebrity crush. :)

I love you, Kristen Stewart. :) You are so beautiful and talented. I would love to perform with you.

reply

Sam is much hotter. Hilary Duff used to be my #1 celebrity crush. :)

I love you, Kristen Stewart. :) You are so beautiful and talented. I would love to perform with you.

reply

Shelby! Sam was cute, but if we are talking about HOT, definitely Shelby.

"Creativity is intelligence having fun." - Albert Einstein

reply

Well Sam is very capable of being pretty as seen in her "Cinderella" dress. So she ( along with Hilary Duff) are not ugly at all.

But I honestly had to say Shelby was hotter, although I didn't like her one bit.

reply