Very vague ending -SPOILER


I really wish there was a bit more closure at the end-so strange. Is he or isn't he ? He just morphed into someone else ...

I did not like how he "lied" about knowing John as if they were friends. If he was John why couldn't he say he knew him that they were friends...? Would have made more sense ...

What's with George getting all the "freebies" throughout the movie ...or we just to infer what a nice guy he is ???

Not my favorite movie -but -ok....

reply

Is he or isn't he ? He just morphed into someone else ...

He is. He was as he was as the young man who left them, and the man as he would be now.

If he was John why couldn't he say he knew him that they were friends...?

The family was just getting back into living again. The mother and sister would have had a really hard time handling it. He led dad into it very gently over the course of the film.

What's with George getting all the "freebies" throughout the movie

One of the store keepers spells it out, saying something to the effect that he'd been helping and volunteering all this time, and this was their way of saying thank you.

One of my very favorite Christmas movies.



reply

Mine too.

reply