Plothole?


I would like to start this post by saying it has been a few years since my last viewing of this movie, but I am fairly certain that my observations are still correct.

So, Jennings sees himself die in the future. He is supposed to die in the room where he is strapped to the chair, relatively early on in the movie. He sends himself the special sunglasses and cigarettes to save his life. So far, so good. The problem I see is everything after that. If Jennings dies there in the vision of the future, how can he see further into his future to know what he would need to survive. He would have died in the room with the chair, so he would never have gotten to the point where he needed anything else than the cigarettes and glasses to MAYBE make an escape.

So, the obvious solution is, Jennings DID send himself the glasses and cigarettes, so he DID make it our if the chair room in his next viewing of the future, and therefore could see the other items he would need. Right, but in that case, the items would have been in multiple envelopes. Every time Jennings saw a death for himself (or a friend), he would send an envelope to himself to help out,

I say all of this based on my somewhat hazy memory of the movie. I remember this being my only thought during a good portion of the movie, and I think it was a big part of me not enjoying the movie all that much (kind of stupid of myself, I know). An I right? Was this explained somewhere in the movie? I know it's just a small flaw if it's a flaw at all, but it is one that bugged me at the time.



Wash dies. Damnit!

reply

i think, as soon as he plan ahead in his head, the future is going to change. He doesn't need to actually send the items for the changes to happen as long as he has the intentions to do so. Then, he can view the causes & effects through the machine without actually executing them until he find a perfect set of items.

So... in short... by looking into the future with the machine, not only his actions changed the future... the future changed as soon as he has the intentions to do so (and he can verify it by watching the future).

reply


I think the more accurate answer is that nothing in this film made sense.



"Get on board, dick."

reply

One thing made sense.
If you could see the future, you would use it to buy a winning lottery ticket.

I was born in the house my father built

reply

Made perfect sense to me. Say I had a future seeing machine in my home and I wanted to see how my upcoming trip to the store is gonna go. If I look into it and see that the store burns down while im inside it, I would obviously make the decision not to go.

If I look into the machine again it wouldn't still show me in the store like before even though I haven't done anything to physically prevent myself from going.

All Jennings had to do was to keep checking the machine and find out what he needs to stuff in that envelope. I'm guessing he saw himself arrested or killed at the bus station and surmised that sticking a bus pass in his envelope keeps him on the right track. All he would have had to do was keep checking his new future and find out what he needs to keep himself alive.

reply