MovieChat Forums > Birth (2004) Discussion > Why I didn't like the movie

Why I didn't like the movie


...because of the annoying soundtrack; vibrations and creepy sounds trying to create "le suspense" which the plot didn't manage to create. Also, the intimate scenes between Anna and little Sean were disturbing , even in the idea of a possible reincarnation. Many parts of the movie were lacking the depth they wanted to transmit. However, I enjoyed Nicole Kidman's acting and haircut...

reply

See, I thought that the soundtrack was perfect! It's actually one of my favourite soundtracks ever. I think that Kidman was marvellous, too. I don't see why that scene was so disturbing. I guess it could be, but it didn't seem disturbing to me at all - if you think that she is still in love with Sean, and that she is falling in love with him again..I just assumed she wasn't even seeing the boy, but that she was projecting Sean in that bathtub instead.

___________________________________
And the Oscar goes to... by a nose, NICOLE KIDMAN!

reply

I'm with you, roxitoxi

reply