MovieChat Forums > The Passion of the Christ (2004) Discussion > Jewish Buffalo News Movie Critic rated t...

Jewish Buffalo News Movie Critic rated this 1/2 out of 5 stars.


Out of 20 years reading his reviews, it's the lowest score I ever saw him give
a movie. Biased much?

His name is Jeff Simon, in case you wonder how I know his religion!

reply

I’m surprised at the half. What is your point at putting his religion, OP?

reply

Um, maybe that it was a slightly biased review since Jews don’t believe the story of Jesus? He should have recused himself from the assignment.

reply

[deleted]

1/2 star is ridiculous. The cinematography alone is worth a star or two. The film's score (which was Oscar nominated) was very well done and Jim Caviezel's performance is excellent.

reply

When the film came out, Mel Gibson came under attack in the press and elsewhere for alleged "Antisemitism". I think it was quite clear there this film became a clashing point for the right-left culture wars, so a cinematic portrayal of the most important story in Christianity was the target of the left's ire.

reply